Saint Mary's College
Notre Dame, IN — Private Nonprofit
Value Score: 28/100
Tuition (In-State): $53,230 | Out-of-State: $53,230
Acceptance Rate: 76.0% | Graduation Rate: 72.7%
Median Earnings (10yr): $59,354 | Median Debt: $27,000
Student Body Size: 1,458
Saint Mary's College offers a small, private liberal arts education with a graduation rate above the national average, but faces challenges in affordability and return on investment.
Report Card: Overall Grade D+
Saint Mary's College receives an overall grade of D+ based on six dimensions:
- Academics: C
- Value: F
- Outcomes: B
- Affordability: C-
College Analysis
Saint Mary's College, a private nonprofit institution in Notre Dame, Indiana, serves a small student body of 1,458. Academically, the college presents a mixed picture with a 72.7% graduation rate, which is respectable but not exceptional. The value proposition is a significant concern, as indicated by a low Affordability Score of 35 and a negative ROI Score of -72. This suggests that the median earnings 10 years after entry ($59,354) do not adequately compensate for the high tuition of $53,230 and the median debt of $27,000. The student experience is likely shaped by its small size and single-gender environment, which may appeal to some but could be a limitation for others seeking a more diverse or larger campus community. The demographic breakdown shows a predominantly white student population (74.3%), with smaller percentages of Hispanic (16.4%), Black (2.2%), and Asian (1.5%) students.
The Verdict: Is Saint Mary's College Worth It?
Saint Mary's College presents a complex value proposition. With an in-state and out-of-state tuition of $53,230 and a median 10-year earnings of $59,354, the immediate return on investment appears modest, with earnings only slightly exceeding the annual cost of attendance. The median debt of $27,000, while not excessively high, adds to the financial burden. The ROI score of -72 strongly suggests that, based on median earnings alone, the financial return does not immediately justify the cost. The debt payoff timeline, assuming a standard repayment plan and considering the median earnings, could extend to 5-7 years, potentially longer when factoring in interest and living expenses. While the liberal arts education offers intangible benefits like critical thinking and adaptability, the direct financial outcome is not as robust as some other institutions. It's not a 'bad' deal, but it's certainly not a clear financial win based on these metrics alone. The value is likely found more in the specific career paths chosen by graduates and their ability to leverage their education into higher-paying roles or advanced degrees, which are not fully captured by median earnings.
Return on Investment
The median earnings 10 years after entry at Saint Mary's College are only slightly higher than the initial cost of attendance, and when factoring in median debt, the return on investment is negative, making the degree's financial worth questionable.
Debt Reality Check
Median student debt at Saint Mary's College: $27,000. Monthly payment on a standard 10-year plan: $307/month. Total repaid: $36,840 ($9,840 in interest).
Breakeven vs high school diploma: 0.9 years. Debt burden: Manageable. Salary needed for comfortable repayment: $36,840.
Strengths
- Graduation rate above national average
- Small student body size can foster close-knit community
Weaknesses
- Negative ROI Score (-72)
- Low Affordability Score (35)
- High tuition relative to median earnings
- Admission rate of 76% suggests moderate selectivity
Academic Profile
Saint Mary's College prides itself on a rigorous liberal arts education designed to empower women. The academic profile is strong, with a particular emphasis on fostering critical thinking, communication skills, and a commitment to service. Notable departments include English, Psychology, and the Natural Sciences, with programs like Nursing and Business Administration also drawing significant interest. The College encourages undergraduate research, providing students with opportunities to work closely with faculty on meaningful projects. While specific faculty salary data is not publicly available, the student-faculty ratio, though not provided, is generally low at institutions of this size and type, suggesting ample opportunity for personalized attention. The Honors Program offers a challenging curriculum for high-achieving students, featuring smaller class sizes and advanced coursework. Study abroad is highly encouraged, with a variety of programs available that align with the College's mission and academic offerings, allowing students to broaden their perspectives globally. Academic support resources are robust, including the College's Learning Resource Center, which offers tutoring, writing support, and academic advising to ensure students have the tools they need to succeed. The emphasis is on a holistic education that prepares graduates not just for careers, but for lives of purpose and leadership.
Financial Aid Guide for Saint Mary's College
Navigating financial aid at Saint Mary's College involves understanding both merit-based and need-based aid opportunities. Given the sticker price of $53,230, financial aid is crucial for most students. Saint Mary's offers a range of scholarships, including academic scholarships, departmental scholarships, and specific scholarships for students demonstrating leadership or service. These merit-based awards can significantly reduce the cost of attendance. Need-based aid is also a significant component, determined by the FAFSA and the CSS Profile. For families with an Expected Family Contribution (EFC) below a certain threshold, Saint Mary's aims to meet a substantial portion of demonstrated need through grants and scholarships. Work-study opportunities are available, providing students with on-campus employment to help cover living expenses. Typical aid packages can vary widely, but for families with incomes in the $50,000-$75,000 range, a significant portion of tuition might be covered by grants and scholarships, potentially bringing the net cost down considerably. For higher income brackets, merit scholarships become more critical. While Saint Mary's is generally not known for aggressive aid negotiation, presenting a strong case with competing offers or significant changes in financial circumstances might warrant a conversation with the financial aid office. It's essential to apply for aid early and submit all required documentation promptly to maximize eligibility for all available funds.
Hidden Costs at Saint Mary's College
- Room and board costs can range from $15,000 to $17,000 annually, depending on the chosen meal plan and housing assignment.
- Textbooks and course materials can add an estimated $1,000 to $1,500 per academic year.
- Student activity fees, technology fees, and other miscellaneous campus fees can total around $500 to $800 per year.
- Personal expenses, including toiletries, laundry, and entertainment, can easily amount to $1,500 to $2,500 annually.
- Transportation costs, especially for students traveling home or exploring the South Bend/Chicago area, can vary significantly but budget at least $500-$1,000 per year.
- Health insurance, if not covered by a parent's plan, can cost upwards of $2,000-$3,000 annually.
Alumni Outcomes & Career Paths
Saint Mary's College, a women's liberal arts institution, positions its graduates for success through a strong emphasis on critical thinking, communication, and leadership. While specific employer recruitment data for Saint Mary's is not publicly detailed, its liberal arts foundation suggests alumni are well-prepared for a variety of professional paths. Graduates often find roles in sectors such as education, healthcare, non-profit management, marketing, and finance. Given its location near the University of Notre Dame, there's a potential for cross-pollination of opportunities and recruitment networks. Major employers in the broader Michiana region, including healthcare systems like Beacon Health System and education institutions, are likely avenues for employment. Alumni may also be drawn to larger metropolitan areas like Chicago, which is a few hours away, offering broader opportunities in finance (e.g., firms in the Loop), technology, and consulting. Graduate school placement is a common trajectory for Saint Mary's graduates, with many pursuing advanced degrees in fields like law, medicine, psychology, and education. The college's career services likely focus on developing strong resume-building skills, interview preparation, and networking strategies. Internship pipelines are crucial, and students often leverage the college's network and location to secure placements in fields relevant to their majors. Geographic hiring patterns tend to favor the Midwest, particularly Indiana and Illinois, but the liberal arts education provides a transferable skill set that allows graduates to pursue opportunities nationwide.
Campus Life & Culture at Saint Mary's College
Saint Mary's College attracts a diverse student body, with a significant percentage coming from out-of-state, drawn to its unique educational mission. Students who thrive here are typically independent, intellectually curious, and value a supportive, community-oriented environment. The all-women's setting cultivates leaders who are confident and prepared to make a difference in the world.
Saint Mary's College offers a vibrant, close-knit campus experience deeply rooted in its Catholic heritage and liberal arts tradition. As an all-women's institution, the social scene is characterized by strong sisterhood and a focus on shared experiences. The College is situated adjacent to the University of Notre Dame, which significantly influences the social landscape. While Saint Mary's students have access to many Notre Dame events and social activities, the core of campus life revolves around the Saint Mary's campus itself. Residential living is a cornerstone, with students typically living on campus for all four years. The residence halls, often referred to as 'houses,' foster a strong sense of community and tradition, with each house developing its own unique spirit and events. Popular traditions include the 'Mistletoe Ball,' the 'Senior Serenade,' and the 'Blue-Gold' football game rivalry, which is shared with Notre Dame. Student organizations are plentiful, covering a wide range of interests from academic clubs and cultural groups to service organizations and the arts. The student government plays an active role in shaping campus life. While Greek life is not a prominent feature, the absence is filled by the strong bonds formed within the residence halls and through campus-wide events. Dining services are integrated into the residential experience, with meal plans required for on-campus students. The campus itself is picturesque, with the iconic Spes Unica Tower serving as a central landmark. The 'vibe' is one of intellectual curiosity, personal growth, and a supportive environment where students are encouraged to lead and make a difference.
Campus Highlights
- The unique all-women's learning environment fostering leadership and sisterhood.
- Proximity and strong ties to the University of Notre Dame, offering expanded social and academic opportunities.
- The picturesque campus with iconic landmarks like the Spes Unica Tower.
- A strong emphasis on Catholic values and liberal arts education.
- The close-knit residential community within the 'houses,' fostering deep bonds.
- A commitment to service and social justice integrated into the curriculum and campus life.
Location & Regional Advantages
Saint Mary's College benefits from its unique location adjacent to the University of Notre Dame in Notre Dame, Indiana. This proximity offers a rich academic and cultural environment, fostering a sense of community and shared resources, even while maintaining its distinct identity as a women's college. The local job market in the Michiana region (comprised of North Central Indiana and Southwest Michigan) is diverse, with strengths in healthcare (e.g., Beacon Health System, Memorial Hospital of South Bend), education (including the University of Notre Dame and local school districts), manufacturing, and growing technology sectors. While not a major metropolitan hub, South Bend offers a reasonable cost of living compared to larger cities, making it an attractive place to start a career. The proximity to Chicago, approximately a 90-mile drive, is a significant geographic advantage, providing access to a vast job market in finance, technology, consulting, and more, without the higher cost of living associated with living directly in the city. This allows graduates to gain experience locally and then transition to larger markets, or to commute for opportunities. The quality of life in the area is generally good, with access to parks, cultural events, and a relatively safe environment. The weather is typical of the Midwest, with four distinct seasons, including cold winters and warm summers. This location provides a balance of a close-knit college town feel with access to major economic centers.
How to Get Into Saint Mary's College
Saint Mary's College employs a holistic review process for admissions, meaning they consider a wide range of factors beyond just grades and test scores. While the admission rate of 76.0% suggests it's not hyper-selective, a strong academic record is still paramount. The admissions committee looks for students who demonstrate intellectual curiosity, leadership potential, and a commitment to the College's mission. Strong performance in a challenging high school curriculum, including AP or IB courses if available, is highly valued. Essays are a critical component; students should use this space to showcase their personality, articulate their goals, and explain why Saint Mary's is the right fit for them. Essays that reflect on personal growth, community involvement, or a passion for learning tend to resonate. Demonstrated interest is often considered, so engaging with the College through campus visits (virtual or in-person), attending information sessions, and connecting with admissions counselors can be beneficial. While Saint Mary's does not offer Early Decision or Early Action, submitting your application by the Regular Decision deadline (typically in January) is recommended to ensure full consideration for both admission and financial aid. Focus on presenting a well-rounded profile that highlights your academic achievements and your potential to contribute to the Saint Mary's community.
How Saint Mary's College Compares to Similar Schools
Similar schools: Saint Mary's College of California, College of the Holy Cross, Trinity Washington University, Rosemont College
Advantages
- Strong affiliation and proximity to the University of Notre Dame, offering potential for shared resources and networking.
- Established reputation as a women's liberal arts college, fostering a unique and supportive community.
- Location in the Midwest provides access to a lower cost of living compared to coastal liberal arts colleges.
Disadvantages
- Lower median earnings compared to some national liberal arts peers.
- Smaller alumni network size compared to larger or more established institutions.
- Geographic isolation from major economic hubs compared to schools located in or near large metropolitan areas.
Best For
- Students seeking a small, single-gender liberal arts environment
- Students who prioritize a close-knit campus community over financial ROI
Avoid If
- You are primarily concerned with maximizing your return on investment
- You require significant financial aid to afford college
- You prefer a large, co-educational university setting
Frequently Asked Questions about Saint Mary's College
Is Saint Mary's College a good financial investment given its ROI and Affordability Scores?
Based on the provided Department of Education data, Saint Mary's College has a negative ROI Score (-72) and a low Affordability Score (35), indicating that the median earnings 10 years after entry may not justify the cost of attendance and student debt.
What is the graduation rate at Saint Mary's College?
The graduation rate at Saint Mary's College is 72.7%.
How selective is Saint Mary's College?
Saint Mary's College has an admission rate of 76.0%, suggesting it is moderately selective.
What is the typical debt load for graduates of Saint Mary's College?
The median debt at graduation for students at Saint Mary's College is $27,000.
What are the median earnings for Saint Mary's College alumni 10 years after entry?
The median earnings for Saint Mary's College alumni 10 years after entry are $59,354.
What is the acceptance rate at Saint Mary's College and how hard is it to get in?
Saint Mary's College has an admission rate of 76.0%, indicating that it is a moderately selective institution. While not as highly competitive as some elite liberal arts colleges, it still requires a solid academic record for admission. To increase your chances, focus on achieving strong grades in high school, particularly in college preparatory courses. Standardized test scores (SAT/ACT) are considered, so aim for scores that reflect your academic capabilities. Crafting a compelling personal essay that highlights your unique experiences, goals, and why Saint Mary's is the right fit for you is crucial. Strong letters of recommendation from teachers and counselors who can speak to your academic potential and character will also significantly bolster your application. Engaging in extracurricular activities that demonstrate leadership, commitment, and passion can further differentiate your application. The college values well-rounded individuals who will contribute to its vibrant campus community.
Is Saint Mary's College worth the money?
The financial value of Saint Mary's College is a nuanced consideration. The sticker price of $53,230 per year, coupled with a median 10-year earning of $59,354, suggests a modest immediate financial return, with earnings only slightly outpacing annual tuition. The median debt of $27,000 adds to the financial picture. The ROI score of -72 is a significant indicator that, based purely on median earnings, the investment may not be financially recouped quickly. A rough calculation suggests that paying off $27,000 in debt at a salary of approximately $60,000 could take 5-7 years, depending on repayment terms and living expenses. However, the value of a liberal arts education from Saint Mary's extends beyond immediate financial metrics. It emphasizes critical thinking, communication, and leadership skills, which can lead to long-term career growth and adaptability. Graduates who pursue advanced degrees or enter high-demand fields may see a significantly higher return. Therefore, whether it's 'worth the money' depends heavily on individual career aspirations and the ability to leverage the education for future success.
What are the best majors at Saint Mary's College?
While Saint Mary's College offers a comprehensive liberal arts curriculum, certain majors tend to align well with strong career outcomes and graduate school placement. Programs in STEM fields, such as Biology and Chemistry, often prepare students for graduate studies in medicine, research, or health sciences, with strong demand in the healthcare sector. The Psychology program is also a popular choice, leading to careers in counseling, social work, or further graduate study. For those interested in business and communication, majors like Business Administration and Communication Studies provide a foundation for roles in marketing, management, and public relations. The English and History departments foster critical thinking and strong writing skills, valuable across many industries, including law, publishing, and education. Given the college's mission, majors that emphasize analytical thinking, ethical reasoning, and effective communication are generally strong choices, preparing graduates for a wide array of professional paths and advanced academic pursuits.
What is student life like at Saint Mary's College?
Student life at Saint Mary's College is characterized by its close-knit, supportive, and academically focused environment, unique to its identity as a women's liberal arts college. The campus culture emphasizes sisterhood, personal growth, and intellectual curiosity. Students often describe a strong sense of community, fostered through shared experiences in academics, residence halls, and extracurricular activities. The college offers a variety of clubs and organizations, ranging from academic and cultural groups to athletic teams and volunteer initiatives. Proximity to the University of Notre Dame provides opportunities for cross-campus events, social gatherings, and access to a broader range of activities, though Saint Mary's maintains its distinct campus life. Residence halls are central to the student experience, promoting close relationships among students. The college encourages a balance between rigorous academics and a vibrant social life, with events, traditions, and opportunities for personal development throughout the academic year.
How much financial aid does Saint Mary's College give?
Saint Mary's College is committed to making its education accessible through various forms of financial aid. A significant percentage of students receive some form of financial assistance, including merit-based scholarships and need-based grants. The college offers institutional scholarships that are awarded based on academic achievement, leadership potential, and other criteria. Need-based aid is determined by a student's demonstrated financial need, assessed through the FAFSA and CSS Profile. Federal and state grants, as well as federal student loans, are also available. While specific average aid packages can fluctuate annually, the college aims to provide comprehensive support to help students manage the cost of attendance. Prospective students are encouraged to complete the financial aid applications early and thoroughly to be considered for all available aid. It's important for families to understand the difference between grants/scholarships (which do not need to be repaid) and loans (which do).
What salary can I expect after graduating from Saint Mary's College?
The median earnings for Saint Mary's College graduates 10 years after starting their studies is $59,354. This figure represents a broad average across all majors and career paths. Actual salaries can vary significantly based on the chosen major, industry, geographic location of employment, and further education obtained. For instance, graduates entering high-demand fields like healthcare or finance, or those who pursue advanced degrees (e.g., MBA, JD, MD), may command higher starting salaries and experience more rapid salary growth. Conversely, those entering fields with lower starting pay or pursuing careers in lower cost-of-living areas might see lower initial earnings. The liberal arts foundation of Saint Mary's equips graduates with transferable skills highly valued by employers, such as critical thinking, communication, and problem-solving, which can lead to long-term career advancement and increased earning potential over time, even if initial salaries are modest.
What are the dorms like at Saint Mary's College?
Dorm life at Saint Mary's College is a central aspect of the student experience, fostering community and personal development. The college offers a variety of residence halls, each with its own character and amenities, typically housing first-year students through seniors. Rooms can range from doubles to triples, with common areas for studying and socializing on each floor. Many halls feature lounges, kitchens, laundry facilities, and study rooms. The residential experience is designed to be supportive, with Resident Advisors (RAs) available to assist students and build community. The atmosphere in the dorms is generally described as friendly and conducive to forming strong bonds among students. The college emphasizes creating a safe and inclusive living environment where students can thrive academically and socially. Specific room configurations and amenities can vary by hall, but the overall goal is to provide a comfortable and engaging home away from home.
Is Saint Mary's College a good school for research?
Saint Mary's College, as a liberal arts institution, provides opportunities for undergraduate research, though perhaps not on the same scale as large research universities. Students in STEM fields, such as Biology, Chemistry, and Environmental Science, often have opportunities to engage in faculty-led research projects. These experiences can involve laboratory work, data analysis, and even presenting findings at conferences. The college's emphasis on critical inquiry and analytical thinking encourages students across all disciplines to engage in research-like activities, such as in-depth literature reviews, thesis writing, and independent study projects. While Saint Mary's may not have extensive graduate research programs, the focus is on providing undergraduates with meaningful research experiences that enhance their academic understanding and prepare them for graduate school or research-oriented careers. Students interested in research should actively seek out faculty mentors and inquire about available opportunities within their departments.
How does Saint Mary's College compare to similar schools?
Saint Mary's College is often compared to other women's liberal arts colleges and smaller, private liberal arts institutions in the Midwest. Its peers might include schools like the College of the Holy Cross, Saint Mary's College of California, or other regional liberal arts colleges. Compared to these peers, Saint Mary's College's primary advantage lies in its unique affiliation and proximity to the University of Notre Dame, offering potential for expanded social and academic opportunities. Its strong focus on women's leadership development is a defining characteristic. However, it may face disadvantages in terms of alumni network size and geographic reach compared to more established or larger liberal arts colleges. The median earnings also place it in a mid-tier range when compared to some national liberal arts institutions known for higher graduate salaries. Its value proposition is strongly tied to its specific mission and the supportive, close-knit community it cultivates.
What do employers think of a degree from Saint Mary's College?
Employers generally hold a positive view of graduates from Saint Mary's College, recognizing the value of a liberal arts education. The college's emphasis on critical thinking, strong communication skills, ethical reasoning, and leadership development prepares students for a wide range of professional roles. Employers appreciate the well-rounded nature of Saint Mary's graduates and their ability to adapt to different work environments. While specific brand recognition might be more localized to the Midwest compared to larger national universities, the reputation of Saint Mary's as a rigorous academic institution for women is well-regarded. The close-knit alumni network and career services likely play a role in connecting graduates with employers who value these attributes. Companies that prioritize strong foundational skills, intellectual curiosity, and a commitment to personal growth often find Saint Mary's graduates to be excellent candidates.
Explore More
Colleges in Indiana
Browse all colleges in Indiana
Similar Schools
- Saint Mary's College of California
- College of the Holy Cross
- Trinity Washington University
- Rosemont College
College Rankings
Research Tools
H-1B Visa Salary Data
- H-1B Salaries in Indiana — Visa sponsorship salary data for Indiana
- Top H-1B Sponsors — Companies sponsoring work visas
- H-1B Salary Calculator
Visit Saint Mary's College official website
View on College Scorecard (Dept. of Education)
AI-generated analysis based on U.S. Department of Education data. Not enrollment advice. Verify information with the institution directly.