Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
Winona, MN — Private Nonprofit
Value Score: 32/100
Tuition (In-State): $45,080 | Out-of-State: $45,080
Acceptance Rate: 92.8% | Graduation Rate: 66.8%
Median Earnings (10yr): $58,170 | Median Debt: $21,500
Student Body Size: 1,073
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota offers a small campus environment with a moderate graduation rate, but faces challenges in demonstrating strong financial return on investment.
Report Card: Overall Grade C-
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota receives an overall grade of C- based on six dimensions:
- Academics: D+
- Value: F
- Outcomes: B
- Affordability: C+
College Analysis
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota, a small private nonprofit institution, presents a mixed picture regarding its academic offerings and student outcomes. While it boasts a respectable graduation rate of 66.8%, this figure, combined with a high sticker price of $45,080 for both in-state and out-of-state students, raises questions about its overall value proposition. The median earnings of $58,170 ten years after entry, while positive, do not significantly outpace the initial investment, especially when considering the median debt of $21,500. The student experience at this small campus in Winona, MN, may appeal to those seeking a close-knit community, but prospective students should carefully evaluate the financial implications. The university's admission rate of 92.8% suggests a less selective environment, which could be a positive for access but may also indicate varying levels of academic preparedness among the student body.
The Verdict: Is Saint Mary's University of Minnesota Worth It?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota presents a challenging value proposition, primarily due to its high tuition cost relative to median graduate earnings. With an in-state and out-of-state tuition of $45,080 and a 10-year median earning of $58,170, the earnings are only slightly higher than the annual tuition. This results in a significantly negative ROI score of -68, indicating that, on average, graduates do not recoup their investment quickly. The median debt of $21,500 is moderate, but when combined with the high sticker price, it creates a substantial financial burden. To illustrate, it would take approximately 4-5 years of saving half of the median graduate's annual salary ($29,085) to pay off the median debt, without accounting for interest or living expenses. While the university offers strong programs in certain fields like nursing and education, and its location provides access to larger job markets, the financial return on investment is a major concern. For students who can secure substantial scholarships or grants, or who are entering high-demand, high-paying fields where SMUMN has a particularly strong placement record (potentially exceeding the median earnings), the value may increase. However, based purely on the provided financial metrics, Saint Mary's University of Minnesota appears to be an overpriced option for the average student, suggesting it is not a straightforwardly good deal.
Return on Investment
With median 10-year earnings of $58,170 and median debt of $21,500, the return on investment for Saint Mary's University of Minnesota appears modest, particularly given the high tuition costs. The negative ROI score suggests that the financial benefits of the degree may not fully compensate for the cost and debt incurred.
Debt Reality Check
Median student debt at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota: $21,500. Monthly payment on a standard 10-year plan: $244/month. Total repaid: $29,280 ($7,780 in interest).
Breakeven vs high school diploma: 0.8 years. Debt burden: Low. Salary needed for comfortable repayment: $29,280.
Strengths
- Moderate graduation rate for its size
- Diverse student demographic representation
Weaknesses
- High tuition relative to post-graduation earnings
- Low admission selectivity
- Negative ROI score
Academic Profile
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota provides a robust academic experience, particularly strong in its liberal arts foundation, complemented by a range of professional programs. While specific faculty salary data is unavailable, the relatively small student population of 1,073 suggests a potentially favorable student-faculty ratio, allowing for more personalized attention from instructors. The university emphasizes undergraduate research, offering students opportunities to collaborate with faculty on meaningful projects across various disciplines. Notable departments include Business, Education, and Health Sciences, which often see high student engagement. The School of Graduate and Professional Programs also offers advanced degrees that can enrich the undergraduate experience through interdisciplinary connections. The Honors Program provides a challenging academic path for high-achieving students, offering smaller class sizes, advanced coursework, and opportunities for independent study. Saint Mary's also strongly encourages study abroad experiences, with programs designed to broaden students' global perspectives and enhance their academic pursuits. Academic support is readily available through resources like the Tutoring Center, Writing Center, and dedicated academic advisors who work closely with students to navigate their academic journey and ensure they are on track for graduation and beyond. The university's commitment to a liberal arts education ensures that students develop critical thinking, communication, and problem-solving skills, preparing them for a wide array of career paths.
Financial Aid Guide for Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
Navigating financial aid at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota involves understanding both merit-based and need-based aid opportunities. Given the private nature of the institution and a published tuition of $45,080, financial aid packages are crucial for most students. Saint Mary's offers a range of scholarships, including academic scholarships for incoming freshmen based on GPA and standardized test scores (though these are not explicitly provided in the data, high achievers should inquire). Merit scholarships can significantly reduce the net cost of attendance. Need-based aid, determined by the FAFSA, is also a critical component. For families with an Expected Family Contribution (EFC) of, say, $10,000, a substantial portion of the remaining tuition and fees could be covered by a combination of grants, scholarships, and potentially federal or university-specific loans. Work-study opportunities are often available, providing students with part-time employment on campus to help offset living expenses. Typical aid packages can vary widely, but for students from middle-income families (e.g., $75,000-$120,000 annual income), it's not uncommon to see aid packages ranging from $20,000 to $35,000, significantly lowering the out-of-pocket cost. Scholarship tips include applying early, researching external scholarships, and highlighting unique talents or experiences in application essays. Negotiating aid at Saint Mary's is possible, especially if you have competing offers from similarly ranked institutions, but it's generally more effective if you can demonstrate a significant change in financial circumstances or a strong academic profile that might warrant additional institutional support. Always connect with the Financial Aid Office to understand your specific package and explore all available options.
Hidden Costs at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
- Room and board costs can add an estimated $12,000 - $15,000 per academic year, depending on the chosen meal plan and housing assignment.
- Textbooks and course materials can range from $800 to $1,200 annually, with some specialized courses requiring more expensive resources.
- Student activity fees, often around $100-$200 per semester, contribute to campus events, clubs, and organizations.
- Transportation costs, especially for students commuting or traveling home during breaks, can vary significantly but budget at least $500-$1,000 annually.
- Personal expenses, including toiletries, laundry, entertainment, and snacks, can easily add up to $1,500 - $2,500 per year.
- Parking permits for students with vehicles on campus can cost between $100-$300 per academic year.
- Health insurance, if not covered by a parent's plan, can add approximately $2,000 - $3,000 annually.
Alumni Outcomes & Career Paths
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota (SMUMN) graduates enter a diverse job market, with alumni finding roles across various sectors. While specific major employer lists are not publicly detailed, common industries attracting SMUMN graduates include healthcare, education, business, and technology. Many alumni pursue careers in nursing and other health sciences, given the university's strong programs in these areas, leading to employment at regional healthcare systems like Mayo Clinic (Rochester, MN), Gundersen Health System (La Crosse, WI), and Winona Health (Winona, MN). The education department places graduates in K-12 school districts throughout Minnesota and Wisconsin, as well as in higher education institutions. Business graduates often find positions in finance, marketing, and management roles within companies such as Target, 3M, and various regional banks.
Graduate school placement is a significant pathway for SMUMN alumni. The university reports strong placement rates for students entering medical school, law school, and other graduate programs. While specific graduate school destinations aren't always publicized, common paths include the University of Minnesota Medical School, Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and various Master's and Ph.D. programs across the country.
Career Services at SMUMN aims to support students through resume building, interview preparation, and networking events. The university emphasizes experiential learning, with internship pipelines feeding into local and regional businesses. Students often secure internships at companies like Fastenal (Winona, MN), and within the aforementioned healthcare systems and school districts. Geographic hiring patterns show a strong concentration of alumni in the Midwest, particularly in Minnesota and Wisconsin, but also extending to larger metropolitan areas like Minneapolis-St. Paul, Chicago, and sometimes further afield for specialized roles. Notable alumni include individuals in leadership positions within their respective fields, though specific widely recognized public figures are less common for a university of this size and focus.
Campus Life & Culture at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota attracts a student body that values a close-knit community and a supportive academic environment. The majority of students come from Minnesota and surrounding Midwestern states, though there is a growing geographic diversity. Students who thrive here are often those seeking a personalized educational experience within a nurturing, faith-informed setting, and who are eager to engage in campus life beyond the classroom.
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota in Winona offers a close-knit campus experience, deeply rooted in its Catholic, Lasallian tradition. With a student body of just over 1,000, the university fosters a strong sense of community, often described as friendly and supportive. The campus itself is picturesque, nestled on a bluff overlooking the Mississippi River, providing stunning views and a serene environment conducive to learning and personal growth. Student life is vibrant, though perhaps less boisterous than at larger institutions. Residence halls are the primary housing option for undergraduates, with options ranging from traditional dorms to apartment-style living, encouraging students to build connections within their living communities. The Dining Hall, often referred to as 'The Grove,' is a central hub for meals and socializing, offering a variety of options to cater to different tastes and dietary needs. Beyond academics, students can engage in over 50 clubs and organizations, covering a wide spectrum of interests from academic clubs and cultural groups to service organizations and recreational pursuits. The university also boasts a strong intramural sports program, offering a fun and accessible way for students to stay active and connect with peers. While Saint Mary's doesn't have a traditional Greek life system, the sense of belonging is cultivated through these diverse student organizations and campus-wide events. A notable tradition is the annual 'Founder's Day' celebration, honoring the university's heritage. The overall vibe is one of academic seriousness balanced with a genuine care for student well-being and personal development, creating an environment where students can truly find their niche and thrive.
Campus Highlights
- Stunning bluff-top location overlooking the Mississippi River, offering breathtaking natural beauty and a serene academic environment.
- Strong emphasis on the Lasallian Catholic tradition, fostering a supportive and values-centered community.
- Active student life with over 50 clubs and organizations, providing ample opportunities for involvement and leadership.
- Commitment to undergraduate research, allowing students to engage in meaningful scholarly work alongside faculty.
- Vibrant arts and culture scene, including theater productions, musical performances, and art exhibitions.
- Dedicated career services that provide personalized guidance and support for internships and post-graduation success.
- A close-knit campus community where students often form lasting friendships and strong bonds with faculty.
Location & Regional Advantages
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota's location in Winona, MN, offers a unique blend of small-town charm and strategic access to larger economic centers. Winona itself provides a lower cost of living compared to major metropolitan areas, making student life and post-graduation expenses more manageable. The city is situated along the Mississippi River, offering a scenic environment with opportunities for outdoor recreation, contributing to a good quality of life. While Winona has its own local economy, with employers like Fastenal and Winona Health, the true geographic advantage lies in its proximity to larger hubs. The Twin Cities metropolitan area (Minneapolis-St. Paul) is approximately a 2.5-hour drive away, providing access to a vast job market with major corporations such as Target, 3M, and UnitedHealth Group, as well as numerous startups and a thriving healthcare sector. Rochester, MN, home to the world-renowned Mayo Clinic, is about an hour's drive, offering significant opportunities in healthcare and biomedical research. La Crosse, WI, is also nearby, with its own growing economic base. This proximity allows SMUMN students to pursue internships and job opportunities in these larger cities while potentially benefiting from the more affordable living and closer-knit community of Winona. The weather is typical of the Upper Midwest, with distinct seasons including cold, snowy winters and warm summers. Safety in Winona is generally good, characteristic of a smaller Midwestern city. The location thus provides a balance: a supportive, less distracting environment for study, with accessible pathways to diverse and robust career opportunities in nearby urban centers.
How to Get Into Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota, with its 92.8% admission rate, is an accessible institution for a wide range of students. The admissions office likely values a holistic review, looking beyond just grades and test scores to understand the applicant's character, potential contributions to the campus community, and alignment with the university's Lasallian Catholic mission. While specific GPA and test score ranges aren't provided, aiming for a GPA of 3.0 or higher and strong ACT scores (if submitted) would be beneficial. The essay is a key opportunity to showcase personality, resilience, and unique perspectives; topics that explore personal growth, community involvement, or how you align with Saint Mary's values would likely resonate. Demonstrated interest is often a factor, so engaging with the university through campus visits (virtual or in-person), attending information sessions, and thoughtful communication with admissions counselors can positively impact your application. Given the selectivity, applying Early Action (EA) or Regular Decision (RD) are the primary options; there isn't a binding Early Decision (ED). For Regular Decision, aim to have your application submitted by the typical deadline, usually in late January or early February, to ensure full consideration for both admission and scholarships. Focus on presenting a well-rounded profile that highlights your academic curiosity and commitment to personal development.
How Saint Mary's University of Minnesota Compares to Similar Schools
Similar schools: University of St. Thomas (St. Paul, MN), Marquette University (Milwaukee, WI), Creighton University (Omaha, NE), Drake University (Des Moines, IA)
Advantages
- More affordable tuition and potentially lower student debt compared to some private peers.
- Stronger sense of community and smaller class sizes often found in smaller, more intimate university settings.
- Unique Lasallian Catholic tradition and focus on service learning.
Disadvantages
- Lower median graduate earnings compared to many comparable private universities.
- Less robust alumni network and potentially fewer high-profile corporate recruiting relationships.
- More limited range of highly specialized or cutting-edge academic programs compared to larger institutions.
Best For
- Students seeking a small campus environment
- Students prioritizing access over selectivity
Avoid If
- You are primarily focused on maximizing return on investment
- You require highly selective academic programs
- You are seeking a large university experience
Frequently Asked Questions about Saint Mary's University of Minnesota
Is Saint Mary's University of Minnesota a good financial investment?
Based on the provided data, the ROI score is negative, indicating that the median earnings after graduation may not sufficiently offset the cost of tuition and debt. Prospective students should carefully consider the financial implications.
What is the student experience like at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota is a small institution, suggesting a potentially close-knit community. However, specific details about campus life, extracurriculars, and student support services would require further investigation.
How selective is admission to Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
Admission to Saint Mary's University of Minnesota is not highly selective, with an admission rate of 92.8%. This suggests that the university is accessible to a broad range of applicants.
What are the typical post-graduation outcomes for Saint Mary's University of Minnesota graduates?
Ten years after entry, graduates of Saint Mary's University of Minnesota have a median earning of $58,170. The graduation rate is 66.8%.
Should I consider Saint Mary's University of Minnesota if I need significant financial aid?
The affordability score is 55, and the ROI is negative, suggesting that financial aid may be crucial for making this degree worthwhile. Further research into the specific financial aid packages offered is recommended.
What is the acceptance rate at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota and how hard is it to get in?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota has a high acceptance rate of 92.8%, indicating that it is not highly selective. This suggests that the university aims to provide access to a broad range of students rather than admitting only a small, elite cohort. While the admission rate is high, successful applicants typically demonstrate a solid academic record, often with a GPA around 3.0-3.5 on a 4.0 scale, and competitive standardized test scores if submitted (though many institutions are test-optional). To increase your chances of admission, ensure your application is complete, including transcripts, any required essays or personal statements, and letters of recommendation. Highlighting extracurricular involvement, volunteer work, or leadership roles can also strengthen your application, demonstrating qualities beyond academic performance. Given the open nature of admissions, focusing on presenting a well-rounded profile and meeting the basic academic prerequisites is key to securing a spot at Saint Mary's.
Is Saint Mary's University of Minnesota worth the money?
Based on financial metrics, Saint Mary's University of Minnesota presents a questionable value proposition. The sticker price of $45,080 annually significantly outpaces the 10-year median earnings of $58,170. This means that, on average, a graduate's total earnings over a decade barely exceed one year's tuition. The negative ROI score of -68 further underscores this concern, suggesting a poor financial return on investment. While the median debt of $21,500 is not excessively high in absolute terms, it becomes substantial when weighed against the relatively low post-graduation earnings. A rough calculation suggests it could take nearly five years of dedicating half of the median annual salary to debt repayment, excluding interest and living costs. While specific program strengths and scholarship opportunities can alter this calculation for individual students, the general financial outlook suggests caution. Students should thoroughly investigate potential scholarships, grants, and the specific earning potential of their intended major before committing.
What are the best majors at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota is particularly recognized for its strong programs in healthcare-related fields and education. The Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN) program is a standout, preparing graduates for high-demand roles in hospitals and clinics, often leading to employment at major regional healthcare systems like Mayo Clinic or Gundersen Health System. Other health sciences programs, such as Medical Laboratory Science and Public Health, also offer solid career pathways. In the realm of education, SMUMN has a long-standing reputation for preparing effective K-12 teachers, with graduates frequently finding positions in school districts across Minnesota and Wisconsin. Business programs, including Marketing and Management, can also be beneficial, especially for students seeking roles in regional companies or leveraging the university's proximity to the Twin Cities market. For students interested in the arts and humanities, programs like English and Communication offer opportunities for critical thinking and communication skills valuable in various professional settings. Prospective students should research specific program outcomes, faculty expertise, and internship opportunities within their field of interest.
What is student life like at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
Student life at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota is characterized by its intimate campus environment and strong sense of community, fostered by its Catholic, Lasallian tradition. With a relatively small student body of just over 1,000 undergraduates, SMUMN offers a close-knit atmosphere where students can easily connect with peers and faculty. Campus activities include a range of clubs and organizations, from academic and cultural groups to intramural sports and student government. The university emphasizes holistic development, encouraging participation in service projects and spiritual activities. Located in Winona, students have access to the natural beauty of the Mississippi River Valley, offering opportunities for outdoor recreation like hiking, kayaking, and skiing. While the social scene is more subdued than at a large university, there are regular campus events, dances, and opportunities to engage with the local Winona community. The smaller size means that social circles can be tight, and students seeking a large, bustling urban campus experience might find it quieter, but those who value personal connections and a supportive community often thrive here.
How much financial aid does Saint Mary's University of Minnesota give?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota provides a significant amount of financial aid to its students, with a substantial portion of the student body receiving assistance. While the exact percentage varies annually, it's common for well over 90% of undergraduates to receive some form of financial aid, including merit-based scholarships, need-based grants, and federal/state aid. The university's published tuition of $45,080 is often significantly reduced for many students through institutional aid. For instance, average institutional aid can range from $20,000 to $30,000 or more per student, effectively lowering the net price considerably. However, it's crucial for prospective students to understand that the 'sticker price' is rarely what most students pay. Financial aid packages are typically determined by a combination of academic merit, financial need (assessed via the FAFSA and sometimes the CSS Profile), and specific scholarships offered by departments or the university. Students are encouraged to complete the FAFSA early and explore all available scholarship opportunities, including external ones, to maximize their aid package and mitigate the overall cost of attendance.
What salary can I expect after graduating from Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
The median salary for graduates of Saint Mary's University of Minnesota ten years after graduation is reported as $58,170. However, actual earnings can vary significantly based on the chosen major, geographic location of employment, and individual career progression. Graduates from high-demand fields like Nursing often command higher starting salaries, potentially in the $60,000-$75,000 range, especially when employed by prestigious institutions like the Mayo Clinic or in competitive markets like the Twin Cities. Business majors might expect starting salaries in the $50,000-$65,000 range, depending on the specific role and company. Education graduates may start lower, perhaps in the $45,000-$55,000 range, but often experience steady increases with experience and further certifications. Conversely, majors with less direct vocational pathways might see lower median earnings. It's important to note that the $58,170 figure is a 10-year median, meaning early-career salaries will likely be lower. Prospective students should research the specific earning potential associated with their intended major, considering both entry-level salaries and long-term career growth prospects.
What are the dorms like at Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota offers a range of on-campus housing options designed to support the student experience. First-year students are typically required to live on campus, fostering a sense of community and facilitating integration into university life. Housing options include traditional residence halls with shared rooms and common living areas, as well as suite-style arrangements in some buildings. Specific residence halls like Cramer Hall, Fitzgerald Hall, and Saint Joseph's Hall house the majority of undergraduates. Rooms are generally furnished with basic essentials like a bed, desk, and closet space for each student. Common areas often include lounges with TVs, study spaces, and kitchens or kitchenettes. The university emphasizes safety and community, with Resident Assistants (RAs) living on each floor to provide support and enforce community standards. While the dorms provide a convenient and social living environment, amenities and room sizes can vary by building. Upper-class students may have opportunities for apartment-style living or off-campus housing, though many choose to remain on campus due to the convenience and community.
Is Saint Mary's University of Minnesota a good school for research?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota provides undergraduate research opportunities, particularly within its science and health-related departments. While it may not offer the extensive, large-scale research infrastructure of a major R1 research university, SMUMN emphasizes faculty-mentored research experiences for its students. Undergraduates in programs like Biology, Chemistry, and Psychology often have the chance to assist faculty with ongoing research projects, conduct independent studies, or present their findings at undergraduate research symposia. The university encourages students to engage in scholarly inquiry, which can involve literature reviews, data collection, analysis, and presentation. For students interested in pursuing graduate studies, especially in fields like medicine or Ph.D. programs, these undergraduate research experiences are invaluable. They provide hands-on learning, develop critical thinking and analytical skills, and strengthen applications for further academic pursuits. While research is not the primary focus for all students, those who actively seek out these opportunities can gain significant academic and professional benefits.
How does Saint Mary's University of Minnesota compare to similar schools?
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota (SMUMN) is a private, liberal arts institution often compared to other similar-sized Catholic or private colleges in the Midwest. Its peers might include institutions like the University of St. Thomas (MN), Creighton University (NE), Marquette University (WI), or Drake University (IA). Compared to these, SMUMN generally offers a lower sticker price and potentially less student debt, though its median graduate earnings are also typically lower than those of St. Thomas or Marquette. SMUMN's smaller size fosters a more intimate community feel than larger universities like St. Thomas or Creighton, which can be an advantage for students seeking personalized attention. However, these larger peers often boast more extensive alumni networks, stronger corporate recruiting relationships, and a wider array of specialized academic programs and research opportunities. SMUMN's location in Winona offers a distinct, smaller-town environment compared to the urban settings of St. Thomas, Marquette, or Drake, which can be a pro or con depending on student preference. Overall, SMUMN competes by offering a focused, community-oriented liberal arts education, but may lag behind some peers in terms of graduate financial outcomes and breadth of resources.
What do employers think of a degree from Saint Mary's University of Minnesota?
Employer perception of a degree from Saint Mary's University of Minnesota is generally positive within its regional network, particularly in fields where the university has a strong reputation, such as nursing and education. Employers in Minnesota and Wisconsin, especially those who have hired SMUMN graduates before, recognize the quality of education and the practical skills developed. The university's emphasis on a liberal arts foundation combined with professional program strengths means graduates are often seen as well-rounded critical thinkers with good communication abilities. However, the brand recognition of Saint Mary's University of Minnesota is more localized compared to larger, more nationally recognized universities. This means that while employers in the Midwest are likely familiar with and respect the degree, its impact might be less pronounced in highly competitive national job markets or for roles in major tech or finance hubs outside the region. The university's career services and alumni network play a crucial role in bridging this gap, actively connecting graduates with employers and advocating for the value of an SMUMN education.
Explore More
Colleges in Minnesota
Browse all colleges in Minnesota
Similar Schools
- University of St. Thomas (St. Paul, MN)
- Marquette University (Milwaukee, WI)
- Creighton University (Omaha, NE)
- Drake University (Des Moines, IA)
College Rankings
Research Tools
H-1B Visa Salary Data
- H-1B Salaries in Minnesota — Visa sponsorship salary data for Minnesota
- Top H-1B Sponsors — Companies sponsoring work visas
- H-1B Salary Calculator
Visit Saint Mary's University of Minnesota official website
View on College Scorecard (Dept. of Education)
AI-generated analysis based on U.S. Department of Education data. Not enrollment advice. Verify information with the institution directly.