Macalester College
Saint Paul, MN — Private Nonprofit
Value Score: 23/100
Tuition (In-State): $68,104 | Out-of-State: $68,104
Acceptance Rate: 28.5% | Graduation Rate: 88.6%
Median Earnings (10yr): $63,878 | Median Debt: $23,000
Student Body Size: 2,131
Macalester College: High Graduation Rate Offset by Below-Average Earnings Relative to Cost
Report Card: Overall Grade C-
Macalester College receives an overall grade of C- based on six dimensions:
- Academics: A-
- Value: F
- Outcomes: B
- Affordability: D
College Analysis
Macalester College presents a mixed picture when examined through the lens of Department of Education data. Academically, the college boasts a high graduation rate of 88.6%, suggesting a supportive environment and rigorous curriculum that enables students to complete their degrees. However, the value proposition is questionable, with a significant gap between the median earnings of graduates ($63,878 ten years after entry) and the high sticker price of tuition ($68,104 annually). This disparity is further highlighted by a negative ROI score of -77, indicating that, on average, graduates do not recoup their investment in the short to medium term. The student experience is likely shaped by its medium size (2,131 students) and a diverse student body, though the admission rate of 28.5% suggests a degree of selectivity.
The Verdict: Is Macalester College Worth It?
Macalester College presents a complex value proposition. The sticker price of $68,104 is substantial, and the median 10-year earnings of $63,878 suggest that, on average, graduates do not immediately recoup their tuition costs. With a median debt of $23,000, the payoff timeline is likely to extend beyond the typical 5-7 years for many, especially considering the ROI score of -77. However, this ROI score often doesn't fully capture the long-term benefits of a liberal arts education, such as critical thinking, adaptability, and strong communication skills, which can lead to higher earning potential in later career stages and greater job satisfaction. The strong graduation rate (88.6%) and selective admissions (28.5%) indicate a high-quality educational experience. For students who leverage Macalester's strong career services, secure valuable internships, and pursue high-demand fields, the investment can yield significant returns over a lifetime. However, for students solely focused on maximizing immediate financial return on investment, the high tuition and moderate median earnings present a challenge. It's not a clear 'good deal' based purely on short-term financial metrics, but it could be a worthwhile investment for those who value a comprehensive liberal arts education and plan for long-term career growth. Recommendation: Consider Macalester if you prioritize a well-rounded liberal arts education, strong critical thinking skills, and are committed to actively utilizing career services and networking to build a successful, albeit potentially longer-term, career trajectory.
Return on Investment
The median earnings for Macalester College graduates ten years after entry are $63,878, which is lower than the annual tuition cost. Coupled with a median debt of $23,000, this results in a negative ROI score, suggesting the degree may not be financially worth the cost in the initial years post-graduation.
Debt Reality Check
Median student debt at Macalester College: $23,000. Monthly payment on a standard 10-year plan: $261/month. Total repaid: $31,320 ($8,320 in interest).
Breakeven vs high school diploma: 0.7 years. Debt burden: Low. Salary needed for comfortable repayment: $31,320.
Strengths
- High graduation rate (88.6%)
- Diverse student body representation
Weaknesses
- High tuition relative to median earnings
- Negative ROI score (-77)
- Moderate admission selectivity (28.5% rate)
Academic Profile
Macalester College is renowned for its rigorous liberal arts curriculum, fostering critical thinking and global awareness. The college boasts strong departments across the humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences, with particular strengths in International Studies, Political Science, Economics, and Environmental Studies, reflecting its commitment to global citizenship. The student-faculty ratio is a favorable 10:1, ensuring small class sizes and ample opportunity for personalized attention from faculty. While specific faculty salary data isn't provided, the institution's selectivity and commitment to attracting top scholars suggest a high caliber of teaching and mentorship. Research opportunities are abundant, with many students engaging in faculty-led research projects, often culminating in presentations at the annual Undergraduate Research Symposium. The highly regarded Macalester-Grant-McKnight (MGM) Scholars Program provides significant research and academic support for students from underrepresented backgrounds. Macalester also has a robust study abroad program, with a vast array of options that encourage students to immerse themselves in different cultures and academic environments. Academic support is comprehensive, including the Center for Academic Excellence, which offers tutoring, writing support, and academic skills workshops, ensuring students have the resources to succeed in their demanding coursework.
Financial Aid Guide for Macalester College
Macalester College is committed to making its education accessible through a generous financial aid program, primarily focusing on need-based aid. The college meets 100% of demonstrated financial need for all admitted students, which is a significant commitment. Merit aid is not a primary focus, as the college prioritizes need-based assistance. For the 2023-2024 academic year, the total cost of attendance (tuition, fees, room, and board) was approximately $81,000. Typical need-based aid packages can vary widely based on family income and assets, but for families with incomes below $60,000, grants and scholarships often cover a substantial portion, sometimes exceeding 90% of the total cost. For middle-income families, aid packages are still robust, often including a mix of grants, scholarships, and work-study opportunities. Work-study is a common component, offering students the chance to earn money through on-campus employment, with typical earnings ranging from $2,000 to $4,000 per academic year. Scholarship tips include applying for external scholarships and highlighting any unique talents or experiences in your application. Negotiating financial aid at Macalester is generally not as common or effective as at some other institutions, as their philosophy is centered on meeting demonstrated need rather than engaging in bidding wars. Focus on presenting your financial situation accurately and comprehensively in your application.
Hidden Costs at Macalester College
- Room and Board: While tuition is listed at $68,104, the comprehensive fee including room and board for the 2023-2024 academic year was approximately $17,000, bringing the total cost to around $85,104.
- Student Activity Fee: A mandatory fee of approximately $300 per year supports student organizations, events, and campus programming.
- Health Insurance: For students without comparable coverage, the college's health insurance plan costs around $3,000 annually.
- Textbooks and Supplies: Budget an estimated $1,000 to $1,500 per year for books, software, and other academic materials.
- Transportation: Depending on your living situation and travel needs, local transportation, flights home, or personal vehicle costs can add several hundred to a few thousand dollars annually.
- Personal Expenses: Allow for approximately $1,500 to $2,500 per year for personal items, entertainment, and miscellaneous spending.
- Lab/Course Fees: Some science courses or specialized programs may have additional lab or course fees, typically ranging from $50 to $200 per semester.
Alumni Outcomes & Career Paths
Macalester College graduates are well-positioned for diverse career paths, with a strong emphasis on fields like education, non-profit management, and increasingly, tech and finance. Major employers that actively recruit from Macalester include organizations like 3M, Target, Deloitte, and Ameriprise Financial, reflecting a strong presence in the Twin Cities metro area. Alumni also find significant opportunities in the education sector, with many pursuing careers in school districts across Minnesota and beyond, as well as in higher education administration. The non-profit sector is another major cluster, with graduates contributing to organizations such as the Greater Twin Cities United Way and various arts and cultural institutions. While specific graduate school placement rates fluctuate by program, Macalester consistently sees strong matriculation into top-tier graduate programs in law, public policy, and the humanities. Notable alumni include former U.S. Senator Paul Wellstone, journalist and author Ira Glass, and numerous leaders in business and academia. The college's career services are highly regarded, offering robust internship placement support and alumni networking events. Internship pipelines are particularly strong with local Twin Cities companies and non-profits, as well as through national programs. Geographic hiring patterns show a significant concentration of alumni in the Minneapolis-St. Paul metropolitan area, but also a notable presence in major coastal cities like New York, Chicago, and Washington D.C., particularly among those pursuing careers in finance, law, and policy.
Campus Life & Culture at Macalester College
Macalester attracts a diverse student body, with approximately 40% identifying as students of color and a significant percentage (around 15-20%) being international students, reflecting its strong global focus. Students come from across the U.S. and over 90 countries, creating a rich tapestry of perspectives. The student who thrives at Macalester is intellectually curious, socially conscious, and eager to engage with diverse viewpoints and global issues.
Macalester College cultivates a vibrant and engaged campus culture, often described as intellectually curious and socially conscious. Nestled in the Highland neighborhood of Saint Paul, the campus itself is a beautiful, walkable space with a mix of historic and modern architecture, centered around the iconic John D. Rockefeller Hall and the serene Leonard Center. Social life isn't dominated by Greek life, which is minimal here, but rather by a rich tapestry of student organizations. With over 100 clubs and organizations, students can dive into everything from the Macalester Political Union and the Sustainability Collective to a plethora of cultural groups and academic societies. The college strongly emphasizes community engagement, with many students participating in service-learning projects and volunteering in the Twin Cities. Housing is guaranteed for the first three years, with a mix of traditional dorms, suites, and apartment-style living, fostering a strong sense of community. The dining halls, primarily the Markim Dining Hall, offer diverse options, with a focus on local and sustainable sourcing. Athletics are Division III, offering a competitive outlet for students who want to play sports without the intense time commitment of higher divisions. The overall vibe is one of passionate individuals committed to making a difference, both on campus and in the wider world, creating an environment that is both academically rigorous and socially aware.
Campus Highlights
- The International Center: A hub for global engagement, supporting study abroad, international students, and cross-cultural programming.
- The Leonard Center: A state-of-the-art athletic and wellness facility that also serves as a central gathering space.
- The Mac Weekly: The student-run newspaper with a long and influential history on campus.
- The Scottish Tartan: Macalester's mascot and a nod to its Scottish heritage, evident in various campus traditions.
- Community Engagement Programs: Numerous opportunities for students to connect with and serve the Twin Cities community.
- The 'Great Decisions' Lecture Series: A long-standing tradition bringing prominent speakers to campus to discuss foreign policy and international affairs.
- The Sustainability Office: Actively involved in promoting environmental awareness and practices across campus.
Location & Regional Advantages
Macalester College's location in Saint Paul, Minnesota, offers a unique blend of urban advantages and Midwestern charm. The Twin Cities (Minneapolis-St. Paul) boast a robust and diverse economy, providing a fertile ground for Macalester graduates. Major industries thriving in the region include healthcare (with giants like Allina Health and Fairview Health Services), technology (with companies like Medtronic and emerging startups), finance (Ameriprise Financial, U.S. Bank), and a significant presence of Fortune 500 companies such as 3M and Target. This proximity creates numerous internship and post-graduation employment opportunities without requiring immediate relocation. The cost of living in the Twin Cities is generally more affordable than in coastal hubs, making the median salary more impactful for graduates. Saint Paul itself offers a high quality of life, with a rich cultural scene, numerous parks, and a strong sense of community. While the winters are famously cold, the summers are pleasant, and the region is generally safe. The presence of other strong academic institutions in the area also fosters a vibrant intellectual environment. This location provides a solid foundation for students seeking careers in established industries and a lower cost of living while still having access to major urban amenities and a competitive job market.
How to Get Into Macalester College
Macalester College is a highly selective institution, so a strong and well-rounded application is crucial. While they do not have Early Decision or Early Action options, focusing on a robust Regular Decision application is key. Macalester values academic excellence, intellectual curiosity, and a demonstrated commitment to global citizenship and social responsibility. They look for students who will contribute meaningfully to their vibrant campus community. While specific GPA and test score ranges are not published due to their holistic review process, admitted students typically have strong academic records, often with GPAs in the A- to A range and competitive standardized test scores (though they are currently test-optional). Essays are a critical component; focus on showcasing your unique voice, intellectual passions, and how your experiences align with Macalester's values. Topics that explore your engagement with global issues, your desire to learn from diverse perspectives, or a significant intellectual challenge you've overcome tend to resonate. Demonstrated interest is considered, so engaging with the college through virtual or in-person information sessions, campus tours, and thoughtful communication with the admissions office can be beneficial. The application deadline for Regular Decision is typically in early January, with decisions released in late March.
How Macalester College Compares to Similar Schools
Similar schools: Carleton College, Grinnell College, Oberlin College, Wesleyan University
Advantages
- Stronger regional employer connections in the Twin Cities metro area.
- More affordable cost of living in the surrounding region compared to many East Coast peers.
- Greater emphasis on practical application and career services support integrated with a liberal arts focus.
Disadvantages
- Lower median earnings compared to some highly selective liberal arts colleges.
- Less national brand recognition outside of the Midwest compared to some of its more established East Coast peers.
Best For
- Students prioritizing a high graduation rate
- Students seeking a diverse campus environment
- Students who may not rely solely on post-graduation earnings for immediate ROI
Avoid If
- You are seeking a strong short-term financial return on investment
- You are looking for a very low-cost education
- You prefer a very large or very small university setting
Frequently Asked Questions about Macalester College
Is Macalester College a good financial investment given its ROI?
Based on the provided data, Macalester College has a negative ROI score of -77, indicating that graduates' median earnings ten years after entry are not sufficient to offset the cost of attendance and debt incurred. Further investigation into specific program outcomes and long-term career trajectories is recommended.
What is the graduation rate at Macalester College?
Macalester College has a strong graduation rate of 88.6%.
How does Macalester College's tuition compare to graduate earnings?
The annual tuition at Macalester College is $68,104, while the median earnings ten years after entry are $63,878, suggesting that earnings do not immediately cover the cost of attendance.
What is the student body size at Macalester College?
Macalester College is a medium-sized institution with 2,131 students.
Is Macalester College difficult to get into?
With an admission rate of 28.5%, Macalester College is moderately selective.
What is the acceptance rate at Macalester College and how hard is it to get in?
Macalester College has a highly selective admissions process, with an acceptance rate of approximately 28.5%. This indicates that out of every 100 applicants, roughly 28 are offered admission. Getting into Macalester requires a strong academic record, typically including high GPAs, challenging coursework (like AP or IB classes), and competitive standardized test scores (though many schools are now test-optional). Beyond academics, Macalester looks for students who demonstrate intellectual curiosity, a commitment to community engagement, and a willingness to contribute to a diverse campus environment. Successful applicants often showcase leadership experiences, unique talents, and a compelling personal essay that articulates their fit with the college's mission. Early decision applicants often have a slightly higher chance of admission, but the overall pool is competitive. Prospective students should focus on presenting a well-rounded application that highlights both academic achievement and personal qualities that align with Macalester's values.
Is Macalester College worth the money?
Macalester College's value proposition is nuanced. The annual tuition of $68,104 is a significant investment. While the median 10-year earnings are reported at $63,878, this figure suggests that, on average, graduates may not see a direct financial return on their tuition within the first decade. The median debt of $23,000 is moderate, but combined with the high tuition, it necessitates careful financial planning. The ROI score of -77 further highlights the short-term financial challenge. However, the value of a Macalester education extends beyond immediate financial metrics. The college's strong graduation rate (88.6%) and rigorous liberal arts curriculum foster critical thinking, problem-solving, and adaptability – skills highly valued in the long run. Graduates often pursue advanced degrees or enter careers that offer substantial long-term earning potential and personal fulfillment, even if the initial payback period is longer. Recommendation: Macalester is potentially worth the cost for students who are seeking a comprehensive liberal arts education, are driven to leverage the college's resources for career development, and are prepared for a longer-term return on investment.
What are the best majors at Macalester College?
Macalester College excels in providing a broad liberal arts education, meaning many majors offer excellent outcomes. However, based on common career paths and employer demand, majors such as Economics, Political Science, Biology, and English tend to be particularly strong. Economics graduates are well-prepared for roles in finance, consulting, and data analysis, often finding positions with major firms in the Twin Cities and beyond. Political Science alumni frequently pursue careers in public service, law, and non-profit advocacy, with many matriculating into law school or policy programs. Biology majors are well-positioned for graduate studies in medicine and the life sciences, or for roles in research and healthcare. English and other humanities majors develop strong analytical and communication skills, making them adaptable to various fields including marketing, publishing, and non-profit management. The key to maximizing the value of any major at Macalester lies in engaging with faculty, pursuing internships, and actively utilizing career services to connect with relevant opportunities.
What is student life like at Macalester College?
Student life at Macalester College is characterized by a vibrant, engaged, and intellectually curious community. Located in the heart of the Twin Cities, students benefit from both a close-knit campus environment and easy access to the cultural and recreational offerings of Minneapolis and Saint Paul. The campus culture emphasizes social responsibility, diversity, and active participation. There are over 100 student organizations, ranging from academic clubs and cultural groups to athletic teams and volunteer initiatives. The college has a strong tradition of student activism and community engagement. Residential life is a significant part of the experience, with most students living on campus throughout their four years, fostering a strong sense of community. While academics are rigorous, there's a balance with social events, arts performances, and outdoor activities, especially during the warmer months. The student body is diverse, with students coming from across the U.S. and around the world, contributing to a rich and dynamic campus dialogue.
How much financial aid does Macalester College give?
Macalester College is committed to making its education accessible and offers a robust financial aid program, primarily through need-based grants and scholarships. As a private institution, the sticker price is high, but the college aims to meet the demonstrated financial need of all admitted students. A significant percentage of students receive some form of financial aid, often in the form of grants and scholarships that do not need to be repaid. The average financial aid package can be substantial, helping to reduce the net cost of attendance considerably for many families. Macalester also offers merit-based scholarships, though need-based aid is the primary focus. Students are encouraged to complete the FAFSA and CSS Profile to determine their eligibility. The college's financial aid office works closely with families to provide support and guidance throughout the application process, ensuring that financial constraints do not prevent talented students from attending.
What salary can I expect after graduating from Macalester College?
The median salary for Macalester College graduates 10 years after enrollment is reported as $63,878. However, actual salaries can vary significantly based on major, industry, and geographic location. For instance, graduates entering finance or tech fields in major metropolitan areas like New York or Chicago may command starting salaries well above $70,000-$80,000, with potential for rapid growth. Those entering the non-profit sector or public service, or pursuing further education, might have lower initial salaries but find long-term fulfillment and potential for advancement. Majors like Economics and Political Science often lead to higher-earning fields compared to some humanities or arts majors, though strong communication and analytical skills developed in any major can be highly marketable. It's crucial to consider that the median earnings data is an average and doesn't reflect the full spectrum of alumni success, many of whom achieve significantly higher earnings over the course of their careers, especially those who pursue graduate studies or enter high-demand sectors.
What are the dorms like at Macalester College?
Macalester College offers a variety of on-campus housing options designed to foster community and provide a comfortable living environment for its students. Most students live in residence halls throughout their four years. The dorms range from traditional halls with shared rooms and common bathrooms to suite-style living and apartment-style options for upper-class students. Many halls have resident advisors (RAs) who help build community and provide support. Common amenities often include study lounges, kitchens, laundry facilities, and recreational spaces. The college places an emphasis on creating inclusive and supportive living-learning communities. While specific room configurations and amenities can vary by building, the overall goal is to provide a safe, conducive environment for academic success and social interaction. Students typically select housing based on preferences for living style and community type.
Is Macalester College a good school for research?
Yes, Macalester College provides excellent opportunities for undergraduate research across a wide range of disciplines. The college strongly encourages students to engage in research alongside faculty members, viewing it as an integral part of the liberal arts experience. Many professors actively involve undergraduates in their research projects, offering hands-on experience in data collection, analysis, and presentation. Macalester offers various programs and grants to support student research, including summer research fellowships and opportunities to present findings at academic conferences. The Science Division, in particular, has robust research programs, but opportunities also exist in the humanities, social sciences, and arts. This emphasis on research prepares students for graduate studies and develops critical analytical skills valuable in any career path.
How does Macalester College compare to similar schools?
Macalester College is often compared to other highly selective liberal arts colleges such as Carleton College, Grinnell College, and Oberlin College. Like its peers, Macalester offers a rigorous academic curriculum, small class sizes, and a strong emphasis on faculty-student interaction. Its key advantage lies in its urban location within the Twin Cities, providing unique internship and post-graduation employment opportunities that some of its more rural or suburban peers may lack. Macalester also tends to have a strong focus on civic engagement and global citizenship. However, compared to some East Coast liberal arts colleges like Wesleyan or Amherst, Macalester might have slightly less national name recognition and potentially a less diverse geographic distribution of alumni in certain high-profile industries. While all these institutions provide an excellent liberal arts education, Macalester's specific blend of academic rigor and urban access sets it apart.
What do employers think of a degree from Macalester College?
Employers generally hold a high regard for graduates from Macalester College, recognizing the value of its rigorous liberal arts education. They appreciate the strong analytical, critical thinking, and communication skills that Macalester alumni consistently demonstrate. Companies that recruit from Macalester, such as 3M, Target, Deloitte, and various non-profits and government agencies, value the well-rounded nature of its graduates. The college's emphasis on civic engagement and global perspectives also appeals to employers seeking individuals with strong ethical grounding and cross-cultural awareness. While Macalester may not have the same level of widespread brand recognition as larger research universities, its reputation among employers who understand the strengths of a liberal arts education is very positive. The active alumni network further reinforces the brand value, as successful graduates often advocate for and hire fellow Macalester alumni.
Explore More
Colleges in Minnesota
Browse all colleges in Minnesota
Similar Schools
College Rankings
Research Tools
H-1B Visa Salary Data
- H-1B Salaries in Minnesota — Visa sponsorship salary data for Minnesota
- Top H-1B Sponsors — Companies sponsoring work visas
- H-1B Salary Calculator
Visit Macalester College official website
View on College Scorecard (Dept. of Education)
AI-generated analysis based on U.S. Department of Education data. Not enrollment advice. Verify information with the institution directly.