CollegeTuitionData — College Data in Plain English

Keuka College

Keuka Park, NY 14478 — Private Nonprofit

Value Score: 65/100 | ROI Score: -63 | Affordability Score: 55/100

Tuition (In-State): $39,332 | Out-of-State: $39,332

Acceptance Rate: 68.1% | Graduation Rate: 53.3% | Retention Rate: 73.4%

Median Earnings (10yr): $58,289 | Median Debt: $27,000

ACT Midpoint: 26

Student Body Size: 966 (small)

Pell Grant Recipients: 49.9% | Federal Loan Rate: 75.2%

Average Faculty Salary: $7,000/month

Tuition & Affordability Analysis

In-state tuition at Keuka College is $39,332 per year, which is near the national average for private institutions.

Out-of-state students pay $39,332/year — a premium of $0 over in-state rates. Over four years, out-of-state students pay approximately $0 more than their in-state peers.

Estimated four-year tuition cost: $157,328 (tuition only, not including room, board, and fees).

What You Actually Pay: Net Price by Family Income

The sticker price rarely reflects what families actually pay. After grants and scholarships, here is the average net price by family income bracket at Keuka College:

  • Families earning $0–$30,000: $19,368/year
  • Families earning $30,001–$48,000: $19,762/year
  • Families earning $48,001–$75,000: $21,808/year
  • Families earning $75,001–$110,000: $30,357/year
  • Families earning $110,000+: $26,748/year

Low-income families receive an average discount of $19,964/year, paying just 49% of the sticker price.

Admissions Snapshot

Keuka College has an acceptance rate of 68.1%, placing it in the Moderately Selective (50–70%) category. This means roughly 355 students apply each year.

The ACT midpoint is 26, 24% above the national average.

Graduate Outcomes & Return on Investment

53.3% of students at Keuka College complete their degree, 14% below the national average. This is below average — prospective students should investigate support services and retention programs.

First-year retention rate: 73.4% (9% below the national average). A retention rate below 75% suggests some students struggle with fit, academics, or affordability.

Graduates of Keuka College earn a median salary of $58,289 ten years after enrollment, 43% above the national average. This represents a $23,289/year earnings premium over the average high school diploma holder, or $698,670 in additional lifetime earnings over a 30-year career.

The median student debt at graduation is $27,000, 26% above the national average. On a standard 10-year repayment plan at 5.5% interest, this translates to approximately $293/month, with a total repayment of $35,160 (including $8,160 in interest).

Debt-to-Earnings Ratio: 0.46x. This is an excellent ratio — graduates carry manageable debt relative to their earning power.

Breakeven Point: Based on the earnings premium over high school graduates, a degree from Keuka College pays for itself in approximately 7 years. This is a reasonable investment timeline.

Financial Aid Profile

49.9% of students at Keuka College receive Pell Grants (federal need-based aid for families earning under ~$60,000), 51% above the national average. This is near the national average, reflecting a typical economic diversity among the student body.

75.2% of students take federal loans, 60% above the national average. This high borrowing rate means most students need loans to attend. Factor loan payments into your decision carefully.

Average faculty salary: $7,000/month, 20% below the national average. Higher faculty salaries generally indicate greater investment in teaching quality and ability to attract experienced professors.

Student Body & Campus Diversity

Keuka College enrolls 966 undergraduate students. As a small institution, students can expect smaller class sizes, closer faculty relationships, and a tight-knit campus community.

Diversity Index: 38/100 (higher = more diverse). The student body is less diverse than average.

Student body composition: White 78%, Hispanic 8%, Black 7%, Asian 1%.

Keuka College: Small Class Sizes and Personalized Education with High Tuition

Report Card: Overall Grade D+

Keuka College receives an overall grade of D+ based on six dimensions:

  • Academics: C-
  • Value: F
  • Outcomes: B
  • Affordability: C+

College Analysis

Keuka College is a Private Nonprofit institution in Keuka Park, NY with approximately 966 students. Keuka College has a strong focus on small class sizes and personalized education, with a graduation rate of 53.3%. The college offers competitive earnings potential with a median 10-year earnings of $58,289, but the high median debt of $27,000 is a concern. Keuka College has a high tuition rate of $39,332, both in-state and out-of-state, which is above the national average for private colleges.

The Verdict: Is Keuka College Worth It?

Keuka College presents a complex value proposition. With a median 10-year earning potential of $58,289 and median student debt of $27,000, the return on investment (ROI) score of -63 suggests a significant financial challenge for many graduates. The tuition of $39,332 is substantial, and the graduation rate of 53.3% indicates that a considerable portion of students may not complete their degrees within the typical timeframe, potentially increasing overall costs and debt. To break even on the median debt of $27,000, assuming 10% of earnings go towards debt repayment, it would take approximately 3-4 years of post-graduation employment, which is relatively reasonable. However, the median earnings are not exceptionally high compared to the cost of attendance. The ROI score strongly suggests that, on average, graduates do not recoup their investment quickly or significantly. While Keuka College offers a unique, intimate learning environment and strong community support, prospective students must carefully consider their major's earning potential and explore all available financial aid options. It is not a clear 'good deal' and may be considered overpriced for the average graduate's financial outcome. It could be a 'hidden gem' for students who leverage its specific program strengths and secure high-paying jobs post-graduation, but the data indicates caution is warranted.

Return on Investment

While the earnings potential is strong, the high tuition and debt levels make the ROI less favorable compared to some other private colleges.

Debt Reality Check

Median student debt at Keuka College: $27,000. Monthly payment on a standard 10-year plan: $307/month. Total repaid: $36,840 ($9,840 in interest).

Breakeven vs high school diploma: 1 years. Debt burden: Manageable. Salary needed for comfortable repayment: $36,840.

Strengths

  • Strong focus on small class sizes and personalized education.
  • Competitive earnings potential.

Weaknesses

  • High median debt of $27,000.
  • Below-average graduation rate.

Academic Profile

ACT Midpoint: 26. Retention Rate: 73.4%.

Keuka College prides itself on a personalized academic experience, leveraging its smaller size to foster strong faculty-student relationships. While specific faculty salaries are not publicly available, the student-faculty ratio, though not provided, is likely to be favorable given the institution's size, suggesting ample opportunities for individual attention. The college is particularly recognized for its strong programs in health sciences, including nursing and occupational therapy, which are often highlighted as areas of excellence. The Department of Education also boasts a solid reputation, preparing students for careers in teaching. Research opportunities are available, though they may be more integrated into coursework and faculty-led projects rather than large-scale, independent undergraduate research centers. Keuka College offers an Honors Program designed to challenge high-achieving students with enriched coursework and opportunities for independent study. Study abroad is encouraged, with various programs available to broaden students' global perspectives. Academic support is robust, with services like the Academic Success Center providing tutoring, academic advising, and workshops to help students navigate their studies and develop effective learning strategies. The emphasis is on providing a supportive environment where students can explore their interests and develop the skills necessary for their chosen career paths.

Financial Aid Guide for Keuka College

Pell Grant recipients: 49.9%. Students taking federal loans: 75.2%.

Navigating financial aid at Keuka College involves understanding both merit-based and need-based opportunities. Given the private, nonprofit status and the listed tuition of $39,332, financial aid packages are crucial for most students. Keuka College is known to offer a range of merit scholarships, often awarded automatically based on academic achievement (GPA and any available test scores, though these are not currently a primary focus). These scholarships can significantly reduce the net cost of attendance. Need-based aid, determined by the FAFSA, is also a critical component. Families with an Expected Family Contribution (EFC) below a certain threshold will likely receive a combination of grants, institutional aid, and federal loans. Work-study opportunities are available, providing students with on-campus employment to help cover living expenses. For families with an annual income between $30,000-$50,000, a typical aid package might combine institutional grants and scholarships totaling $20,000-$25,000, bringing the net tuition closer to $14,000-$19,000, plus room and board. Families with higher incomes may still qualify for some merit aid, but need-based grants will be less substantial. Scholarship tips include applying early, thoroughly completing the FAFSA and CSS Profile (if required), and researching external scholarships. Negotiating aid at Keuka College is generally less common than at larger, more research-intensive universities. While presenting a competing offer might be considered in specific circumstances, the college's aid philosophy tends to be more standardized based on established criteria. It's advisable to contact the Financial Aid Office directly to discuss individual circumstances.

Hidden Costs at Keuka College

  • Room and board costs, which are separate from tuition, can add approximately $15,000 to $18,000 per academic year.
  • Textbooks and course materials can range from $800 to $1,200 annually, depending on the program of study.
  • Student activity fees, often around $200-$300 per semester, contribute to campus events and organizations.
  • Transportation costs, especially for students commuting from further distances or traveling home, can vary widely but budget at least $500-$1,000 annually.
  • Personal expenses, including toiletries, laundry, entertainment, and snacks, can easily add up to $1,000-$2,000 per year.
  • Health insurance, if not covered by a parent's plan, can cost upwards of $2,000-$3,000 annually.
  • Parking permits for students with vehicles can range from $100 to $250 per year.

Alumni Outcomes & Career Paths

Keuka College graduates enter a diverse job market, with many finding opportunities within healthcare, education, and business sectors. While specific major employer data for Keuka is not publicly detailed, institutions of its size and type often see alumni placed in regional healthcare systems like Rochester Regional Health, UR Medicine, and smaller community hospitals in the Finger Lakes region. In education, graduates are frequently employed by local school districts such as Penn Yan Central School District or Geneva City School District, and also pursue roles in early childhood education centers. Business-oriented graduates may find positions in regional banks like Five Star Bank or manufacturing firms in the surrounding areas.

Keuka College emphasizes experiential learning, and its internship pipeline is a crucial component of career preparation. Students often complete internships at organizations like the Yates County Chamber of Commerce, local non-profits, and within their chosen academic departments. While graduate school placement rates are not explicitly published, programs like psychology and education often see a portion of their graduates continue their studies at institutions like SUNY Oswego, Nazareth College, or St. John Fisher University for advanced degrees. Notable alumni are not widely publicized, but the college likely boasts successful graduates in regional leadership roles. Career services at Keuka College are generally praised for their personalized approach, offering resume workshops, mock interviews, and career counseling tailored to a smaller student body. Geographic hiring patterns show a strong tendency for graduates to remain within New York State, particularly in the Finger Lakes and Rochester metropolitan areas, though some may venture to larger cities like Buffalo or Syracuse for broader opportunities.

Campus Life & Culture at Keuka College

Keuka College attracts a student body that values a close-knit, supportive environment and often has a strong connection to the Finger Lakes region. The student population tends to be predominantly from New York State, with a growing number of out-of-state students seeking a personalized college experience. Students who thrive here are often independent, engaged, and appreciate the blend of academic challenge and outdoor-focused lifestyle.

Nestled on the picturesque shores of Keuka Lake, Keuka College offers a close-knit community with a distinctively serene and engaged atmosphere. The 'Vibe' here is often described as friendly, supportive, and deeply connected to the natural beauty of the Finger Lakes region. With a student body of under 1,000, personal connections are paramount. Residential life is a cornerstone, with most students living on campus throughout their undergraduate careers. The college offers a variety of housing options, from traditional residence halls in areas like Dahlstrom Hall to apartment-style living for upperclassmen, fostering a sense of community and shared experience. Dining services are centered around the Lightner Dining Hall, offering a range of options to fuel busy student lives. Student organizations are plentiful and diverse, covering academic interests, cultural groups, spiritual life, and recreational pursuits. Keuka College doesn't have a Greek life presence, which contributes to a more unified social scene focused on campus-wide events and activities. Athletics are a significant part of the student experience, with the Keuka Wolves competing in the Empire 8 Conference. Sports like basketball, soccer, and lacrosse are popular, drawing enthusiastic crowds to games. Beyond organized activities, students often take advantage of the lake for recreation, from kayaking and swimming in warmer months to enjoying the scenic views year-round. Campus traditions, such as the annual 'Lighting of the Quad' during the holiday season and the 'Senior Send-off' event, further solidify the sense of belonging and shared history. The small size and unique location foster an environment where students can truly find their niche and build lasting relationships.

Campus Highlights

  • Stunning Keuka Lakefront Location: Direct access to the lake offers unique recreational and scenic opportunities.
  • Strong Health Sciences Programs: Renowned nursing and occupational therapy programs attract many students.
  • Emphasis on Experiential Learning: Opportunities for internships and hands-on projects are integrated into the curriculum.
  • Close-Knit Community Feel: The small student body fosters strong relationships and a supportive atmosphere.
  • Commitment to Service: Many students and faculty are involved in community service initiatives.
  • The 'Keuka Experience': A unique blend of academic rigor, personal growth, and outdoor engagement.
  • Dedicated Faculty Mentorship: Small class sizes facilitate close interaction and guidance from professors.

Location & Regional Advantages

Keuka Park, NY, offers a picturesque setting on the eastern shore of Keuka Lake, providing a tranquil environment conducive to focused study. The local job market in the Yates County and surrounding Finger Lakes region is primarily driven by agriculture (wine industry), tourism, healthcare, and education. While not a major industrial hub, the proximity to Rochester (approximately 1.5 hours away) provides access to a larger metropolitan job market with diverse opportunities in advanced manufacturing, technology, and healthcare. The cost of living in the Keuka Lake region is generally lower than in major metropolitan areas, making student debt potentially more manageable post-graduation.

Quality of life is a significant draw, with abundant outdoor recreational activities including boating, hiking, and exploring the numerous wineries. The area is known for its natural beauty and a slower pace of life, which appeals to students seeking a close-knit community. Weather is typical of upstate New York, with four distinct seasons, including cold, snowy winters and warm, pleasant summers. Safety is generally high in this rural setting. The location's primary advantage for career opportunities lies in its ability to foster strong relationships with regional employers, offering students a chance to build local networks. However, the limited presence of large corporations or cutting-edge industries within immediate proximity means graduates seeking highly specialized or fast-paced tech careers might need to relocate to larger urban centers.

How to Get Into Keuka College

Keuka College's admission rate of 68.1% indicates a moderately selective admissions process. While there isn't an Early Decision or Early Action option that offers a significant advantage, applying by the regular decision deadline is crucial. The admissions committee likely values a holistic review, looking beyond just GPA and test scores (which are not currently a major factor, as indicated by the lack of reported averages). They seek students who demonstrate a genuine interest in Keuka's programs and community, and who will contribute positively to campus life. Strong essays that showcase personality, resilience, and a clear understanding of why Keuka is the right fit are highly recommended. Demonstrated interest can be shown through campus visits (virtual or in-person), attending information sessions, and engaging with admissions counselors. While specific GPA ranges aren't published, successful applicants typically have a solid academic record with a B average or higher. The application timeline should involve submitting your application and all supporting materials (transcripts, essays, letters of recommendation) well before the regular decision deadline, typically in late winter or early spring (around February or March).

How Keuka College Compares to Similar Schools

Similar schools: Nazareth College, St. John Fisher University, Roberts Wesleyan University, D'Youville University

Advantages

  • More affordable tuition compared to some private peers.
  • Strong emphasis on experiential learning and internships, particularly in healthcare and education.
  • Unique, intimate campus setting on Keuka Lake offering a distinct student experience.

Disadvantages

  • Lower graduation rate compared to many competitors.
  • Less robust alumni network and fewer national employer connections.
  • Median earnings are lower than some comparable institutions.

Best For

  • Students seeking a more diverse student body may want to consider other options.
  • Prospective students with a lower tolerance for debt should carefully consider the high median debt.

Avoid If

  • Students looking for a more affordable option may want to explore other private colleges.
  • Those seeking a higher graduation rate might consider other institutions.

Frequently Asked Questions about Keuka College

How much does it cost to attend Keuka College?

In-state tuition at Keuka College is $39,332 per year, and out-of-state tuition is $39,332 per year. The median student debt at graduation is $27,000.

What is the acceptance rate at Keuka College?

Keuka College has an acceptance rate of 68.1%.

What is the graduation rate at Keuka College?

Keuka College has a graduation rate of 53.3%.

How much do Keuka College graduates earn?

The median earnings for Keuka College graduates 10 years after enrollment is $58,289. With median debt of $27,000, graduates earn roughly 2.2x their debt level annually.

How big is Keuka College?

Keuka College has approximately 966 students and is classified as a small institution. It is located in Keuka Park, NY and is a Private Nonprofit institution.

Is Keuka College worth the cost?

Keuka College has an ROI score of -63 out of 100. With in-state tuition of $39,332 per year and median post-graduation earnings of $58,289, the data suggests the return on investment may be below average.

Where is Keuka College located?

Keuka College is located in Keuka Park, NY. It is a Private Nonprofit institution with approximately 966 students.

How much student debt do Keuka College graduates have?

The median student debt for Keuka College graduates is $27,000. With median earnings of $58,289 ten years after enrollment, graduates can expect a debt-to-income ratio of 46%.

Is Keuka College a good college?

Keuka College has a graduation rate of 53.3% and median post-graduation earnings of $58,289. 78% of students are white, indicating a predominantly white student body.

How does Keuka College compare to similar colleges?

The college has a high admission rate of 68.08%, suggesting it may be more accessible than some private colleges. Compared to peer institutions, Keuka College offers a personalized education with strong earning potential but at a high cost.

What career prospects do Keuka College graduates have?

Graduates from Keuka College are well-positioned for careers in fields that value small class sizes and personalized education.

What should prospective students know about Keuka College?

Keuka College holds a strong position in the market for private colleges that emphasize small class sizes and personalized education.

What makes Keuka College stand out?

The median debt of $27,000 is relatively high compared to other private colleges.

What are the pros and cons of attending Keuka College?

The college's graduation rate is below the national average for private colleges.

Explore More

Colleges in New York

Browse all colleges in New York

Similar Schools

College Rankings

Research Tools

H-1B Visa Salary Data

Visit Keuka College official website

View on College Scorecard (Dept. of Education)

Analysis based on U.S. Department of Education data. Not enrollment advice. Verify information with the institution directly.