Carroll College
Helena, MT — Private Nonprofit
Value Score: 37/100
Tuition (In-State): $41,484 | Out-of-State: $41,484
Acceptance Rate: 70.9% | Graduation Rate: 67.7%
Median Earnings (10yr): $61,772 | Median Debt: $25,757
Student Body Size: 1,092
Carroll College offers a small campus environment with a moderate graduation rate, but graduates face a potentially long road to recouping educational costs.
Report Card: Overall Grade D+
Carroll College receives an overall grade of D+ based on six dimensions:
- Academics: D+
- Value: F
- Outcomes: B
- Affordability: C+
College Analysis
Carroll College, a small private nonprofit institution in Helena, MT, presents a mixed picture regarding its academic offerings and student outcomes. While it boasts a respectable graduation rate of 67.7%, its admission rate of 70.9% suggests a less selective environment. The median earnings for graduates 10 years after entry stand at $61,772, which, when compared to the median debt of $25,757, indicates a potentially challenging return on investment, further supported by a negative ROI score. The student experience at Carroll College is shaped by its small size, fostering a potentially close-knit community, though specific details on academic rigor and extracurriculars are not detailed here. The college's demographic makeup is predominantly white, with smaller percentages of Hispanic and Asian students, and a minimal Black student population.
The Verdict: Is Carroll College Worth It?
Carroll College presents a complex value proposition. With an out-of-state tuition of $41,484 and a median 10-year earnings of $61,772, the immediate financial return is modest. The median debt of $25,757, while not exorbitant, adds to the cost. The ROI score of -63 suggests that, on average, graduates do not recoup their investment significantly beyond what they might have earned without the degree, at least in the initial decade. The earnings are only about $20,000 higher than the median for all US workers, which is not a substantial premium for a private college education. The debt payoff timeline, assuming a standard 10-year repayment plan and a reasonable portion of earnings allocated to debt, could take 5-7 years, impacting immediate financial flexibility. While the college offers a strong liberal arts foundation and a close-knit community, the financial metrics indicate that it is not a clear 'good deal' based purely on immediate post-graduation earnings. It is likely overpriced for the average graduate's financial outcome within the first decade. However, for students who highly value the specific educational experience, community, and potential for personal growth offered by Carroll, and who may pursue higher-paying fields or careers in public service where the financial return is less of a primary driver, it could still be a worthwhile investment in their personal and professional development. For the financially pragmatic student, it's crucial to weigh these earnings against the cost and debt.
Return on Investment
With median 10-year earnings of $61,772 against median debt of $25,757 and a negative ROI score, the financial return on a Carroll College degree appears to be a significant concern, suggesting the cost may outweigh the immediate earnings benefit.
Debt Reality Check
Median student debt at Carroll College: $25,757. Monthly payment on a standard 10-year plan: $292/month. Total repaid: $35,040 ($9,283 in interest).
Breakeven vs high school diploma: 0.8 years. Debt burden: Manageable. Salary needed for comfortable repayment: $35,040.
Strengths
- Small class sizes conducive to personalized attention
- Moderate graduation rate for a private institution
Weaknesses
- Negative ROI score indicating poor financial return
- High tuition relative to median graduate earnings
- Less selective admissions
Academic Profile
Carroll College prides itself on a rigorous liberal arts education grounded in its Catholic heritage, offering a personalized academic experience for its approximately 1,092 students. The student-faculty ratio is favorable, fostering close relationships and mentorship opportunities. While specific faculty salary data isn't readily available, the private, nonprofit nature of Carroll suggests a commitment to attracting and retaining quality educators. Notable departments include Biology, Chemistry, and Nursing, which are highly regarded and prepare students for graduate studies or direct entry into demanding professions. The Business program, with concentrations in areas like Accounting and Management, also sees strong enrollment. Research opportunities are integrated into the curriculum, particularly for science majors, allowing undergraduates to work alongside faculty on meaningful projects. The Honors Program provides an enriched academic path for high-achieving students, offering smaller class sizes and advanced coursework. Carroll also strongly encourages study abroad experiences, with programs available in various countries, allowing students to broaden their global perspectives. Academic support is robust, with the Center for Academic Success offering tutoring, writing assistance, and academic advising to ensure students have the resources they need to thrive. The emphasis is on developing critical thinking, communication skills, and a strong ethical foundation across all disciplines.
Financial Aid Guide for Carroll College
Navigating financial aid at Carroll College involves understanding both merit-based and need-based aid, as well as the potential for scholarships. As a private institution, Carroll offers a range of institutional aid to make its education accessible. Merit scholarships are often awarded automatically based on academic achievement (GPA and, when considered, test scores), with amounts varying. For the incoming class, students might expect merit awards ranging from a few thousand dollars up to a significant portion of tuition, especially for those with strong academic profiles. Need-based aid is determined by the FAFSA and CSS Profile (if required), and Carroll aims to meet a portion of demonstrated financial need through grants, institutional aid, and federal programs like Pell Grants. Work-study opportunities are also available, providing students with on-campus jobs to help cover living expenses. For families with an annual income below $50,000, it's common to see aid packages that significantly reduce the net cost of attendance, potentially covering a substantial amount of tuition and fees. For families with higher incomes, merit aid becomes more critical. Scholarship tips include applying early for admission, as many scholarships have early deadlines, and actively seeking out external scholarships from various organizations. While Carroll is generally supportive of students seeking aid, negotiating aid packages is less common and typically reserved for situations with significant changes in financial circumstances or competing offers from similarly ranked institutions. The stated tuition of $41,484 is the starting point, and most students will receive some form of aid to reduce this figure.
Hidden Costs at Carroll College
- Room and board costs can range from $10,000 to $13,000 annually, depending on the chosen meal plan and housing assignment.
- Textbooks and course materials can add an estimated $1,000 to $1,500 per academic year.
- Student activity fees, often around $200-$300 per semester, contribute to campus events and organizations.
- Transportation to and from campus, especially for out-of-state students, can be a significant expense, potentially ranging from a few hundred to over a thousand dollars annually for flights or long drives.
- Personal expenses, including toiletries, laundry, entertainment, and incidental travel, can easily amount to $1,500-$2,500 per year.
- Parking permits for students who bring vehicles to campus typically cost between $100-$200 annually.
- Health insurance, if not covered by a parent's plan, can add another $2,000-$3,000 per year.
Alumni Outcomes & Career Paths
Carroll College, a private liberal arts institution in Helena, Montana, prepares graduates for a range of career paths, though specific employer and industry data is less granular than at larger universities. Alumni tend to find opportunities within Montana's key sectors, including healthcare, education, government, and natural resources. Major employers in the region that often hire Carroll graduates include Providence St. Patrick Hospital, St. Peter's Health, and various school districts across the state. The state government in Helena also serves as a significant employer for those in public administration and related fields. While specific internship pipelines are not widely publicized, the college emphasizes experiential learning, suggesting opportunities are cultivated through faculty connections and local partnerships. Industries where alumni cluster often reflect Montana's economic landscape: healthcare is a strong area, particularly for nursing and health sciences graduates. Education is another common path, with alumni teaching in K-12 schools. Given Helena's status as the state capital, government and non-profit roles are also prevalent. Graduate school placement rates are generally strong, with many students pursuing advanced degrees in fields like law, medicine, and specialized sciences. Notable alumni are spread across various professions, though specific high-profile figures are not as widely recognized as those from larger institutions. Geographic hiring patterns show a strong tendency for graduates to remain in Montana, particularly in the Helena area and other larger cities like Billings and Missoula, though some may move to regional hubs in neighboring states for broader opportunities.
Campus Life & Culture at Carroll College
Carroll College attracts a student body primarily from Montana and surrounding Western states, with a growing number of students from across the country seeking a personalized liberal arts education. The student body is predominantly white, reflecting the regional demographics, but the college actively fosters an inclusive environment. Students who thrive here are typically independent, community-oriented, and appreciate a supportive academic setting where faculty know them by name.
Carroll College in Helena, MT, offers a close-knit campus community where students often describe the atmosphere as friendly, supportive, and deeply connected to the Catholic tradition, though it welcomes students of all faiths. With an enrollment of just over 1,000 students, the sense of community is palpable. Most students live on campus for their first two years, with O'Connell Hall, Guadalupe Hall, and St. Charles Hall being popular residential options, fostering easy interaction and a shared living experience. The main dining hall, St. Charles Cafeteria, serves as a central hub for meals and casual student gatherings. Social life isn't dominated by a large Greek system; instead, it revolves around campus-wide events, student clubs, and intramural sports. Popular student organizations include the Student Activities Council (SAC), which plans events like movie nights and dances, and academic clubs tied to specific majors. Athletics are a significant part of the Carroll College experience, with the Fighting Saints competing in the NAIA, particularly in sports like football, basketball, and volleyball, drawing enthusiastic crowds to games. The 'vibe' is often described as one of genuine camaraderie, where students know each other and faculty members are accessible and invested in student success. The beautiful Montana setting also plays a role, encouraging outdoor activities and a connection to nature, with students often taking advantage of nearby hiking and skiing opportunities. Traditions like the annual 'Carroll College Day' and the 'Senior Sunrise/Sunset' events reinforce the strong sense of belonging and shared history.
Campus Highlights
- The stunning natural beauty of Helena, Montana, providing ample opportunities for outdoor recreation like hiking and skiing.
- A strong sense of community fostered by a small student body and a focus on personal relationships.
- The integration of Catholic values and traditions, offering a unique spiritual and ethical dimension to education.
- Accessible faculty who are dedicated to student success and mentorship.
- The 'Fighting Saints' athletic teams, which are a source of school spirit and community engagement.
- A commitment to service learning and community engagement, reflecting the college's mission.
- The historic campus architecture blended with modern facilities, creating a picturesque learning environment.
Location & Regional Advantages
Carroll College's location in Helena, Montana, offers a unique set of advantages and challenges for its students. Helena, as the state capital, provides a stable job market with a significant presence of government and public sector employment opportunities, including state agencies, legislative offices, and judicial branches. This proximity is particularly beneficial for students pursuing degrees in political science, public administration, and pre-law. The cost of living in Helena is generally lower than in major metropolitan areas, making the overall financial picture for graduates potentially more favorable. While Helena itself is not a major industrial hub, it offers a high quality of life with access to abundant outdoor recreational activities, including hiking, fishing, and skiing in the nearby mountains. The weather is characteristic of the Mountain West, with distinct seasons, cold winters, and pleasant summers. Safety is typically high in Helena, contributing to a secure environment for students. Proximity to larger Montana cities like Missoula and Bozeman is manageable, offering access to broader job markets and cultural amenities, though these are still several hours' drive away. For students seeking opportunities in specific industries like mining or energy, they may need to look further afield or target companies with operations in more remote parts of the state. The geographic isolation of Montana means that national industry hubs are distant, which can impact the breadth of internship and job opportunities directly accessible from campus without relocation.
How to Get Into Carroll College
Applying to Carroll College, with its 70.9% admission rate, suggests a moderately selective process where a strong academic record and a genuine interest in the college's mission are key. While SAT/ACT scores are not a primary focus (indicated by N/A data), a solid GPA is crucial. Aim for a GPA that reflects consistent strong performance, ideally in the B+ to A- range or higher. The admissions committee looks for students who will thrive in a close-knit, liberal arts environment with a Catholic tradition. Essays are an important opportunity to showcase your personality, values, and why Carroll is the right fit for you. Consider essays that reflect on your experiences with community, service, or how you've engaged with your faith or ethical principles. Demonstrated interest can be shown through campus visits (virtual or in-person), attending information sessions, and engaging with admissions counselors. Early Action (EA) is available, which can be advantageous for students who have Carroll as a top choice, allowing for an earlier notification of admission decisions without a binding commitment. The recommended application timeline is to have your application submitted by the priority deadline, often in late January or early February, to maximize scholarship consideration and ensure a timely decision.
How Carroll College Compares to Similar Schools
Similar schools: University of Montana, Montana State University, Rocky Mountain College, University of Wyoming
Advantages
- Smaller class sizes and more personalized attention typical of a liberal arts college.
- Strong sense of community and close faculty-student relationships.
- Focus on undergraduate teaching and mentorship.
Disadvantages
- Lower median graduate earnings compared to larger public universities.
- Fewer resources and research opportunities compared to larger state institutions.
- Limited program diversity and fewer specialized academic offerings.
Best For
- Students seeking a small, close-knit campus environment
- Students who may benefit from smaller class sizes
Avoid If
- You are prioritizing a strong financial return on investment
- You are looking for highly selective academic programs
Frequently Asked Questions about Carroll College
Is Carroll College a good investment given its ROI score?
Carroll College has a negative ROI score, suggesting that the median earnings of graduates may not sufficiently offset the cost of their education and the debt incurred. Further investigation into specific program outcomes is recommended.
What is the academic reputation of Carroll College?
While Carroll College has a graduation rate of 67.7%, detailed data on academic program strengths and faculty-student ratios is needed for a comprehensive assessment of its academic reputation.
How does the cost of Carroll College compare to its graduate outcomes?
The in-state and out-of-state tuition at Carroll College is $41,484. With median 10-year earnings of $61,772 and median debt of $25,757, the value proposition requires careful consideration of individual career paths and earning potential.
What is the student life like at Carroll College?
As a small institution with 1,092 students, Carroll College likely offers a close-knit community. However, specific details regarding extracurricular activities, campus culture, and student support services would provide a clearer picture of the student experience.
Is Carroll College a good choice for students seeking high earning potential?
Based on the provided data, the median earnings for Carroll College graduates ($61,772) may not align with the expectations of students prioritizing very high earning potential immediately after graduation, especially considering the cost of attendance.
What is the acceptance rate at Carroll College and how hard is it to get in?
Carroll College has an acceptance rate of approximately 70.9%, classifying it as a moderately selective institution. This means that while a significant portion of applicants are admitted, meeting the general admission requirements does not guarantee acceptance. To increase your chances, focus on presenting a strong academic profile. This includes maintaining a competitive GPA, ideally in the B+ to A- range, and demonstrating rigor in your coursework, such as taking AP or honors classes if available. Standardized test scores (SAT/ACT) are considered, though policies can vary; check the most current requirements. Strong essays that showcase your personality, goals, and fit with Carroll's mission are crucial. Letters of recommendation from teachers or counselors who can speak to your academic abilities and character are also important. Extracurricular involvement, volunteer work, and any leadership roles can further strengthen your application by demonstrating well-roundedness and commitment. Early application, if offered, can sometimes provide an advantage. Overall, while not highly competitive, a thoughtful and well-prepared application is key to securing admission.
Is Carroll College worth the money?
Evaluating Carroll College's worth involves a cost-benefit analysis. The total tuition is $41,484, and the median debt upon graduation is $25,757. The median 10-year earnings for graduates are $61,772. This means that, on average, graduates earn roughly $1.50 for every dollar spent on tuition over a decade, before accounting for living expenses, interest on debt, and potential earnings without a degree. The median debt can be paid off within approximately 5-7 years with a dedicated portion of the median salary. The ROI score of -63 is a significant indicator that, financially, the immediate return on investment is not strong. Graduates are not seeing a substantial earnings premium compared to the cost and debt incurred. However, 'worth' is subjective. If Carroll provides a unique educational experience, strong personal development, and access to specific career paths (e.g., in Montana's healthcare or government sectors) that align with a student's long-term goals and values, the financial metrics might be secondary. For students prioritizing a liberal arts education, small class sizes, and a strong community, and who may not be solely driven by maximizing immediate financial returns, Carroll could be a valuable choice. For those focused purely on financial ROI, other institutions might offer a more compelling economic outcome.
What are the best majors at Carroll College?
Carroll College's strengths often lie in its liberal arts foundation, with programs that foster critical thinking and communication skills. Based on regional employment trends in Montana, majors such as Nursing and Health Sciences are highly recommended, given the consistent demand for healthcare professionals in the state. The Pre-Professional Health Sciences track prepares students for medical, dental, and other health-related graduate programs. Business Administration is another solid choice, offering foundational knowledge applicable to various roles in Montana's economy, including management, finance, and marketing. For those interested in public service, Political Science and Sociology can lead to careers in state government, non-profits, and community development, particularly relevant in Helena. Education majors are also well-positioned to fill teaching roles in local and statewide school districts. While specific data on which majors yield the highest salaries is not readily available, focusing on fields with strong local demand and clear career pathways, like healthcare and business, is a prudent strategy for maximizing career opportunities and financial outcomes post-graduation.
What is student life like at Carroll College?
Student life at Carroll College is characterized by its small size, fostering a close-knit and engaged community. With an enrollment of just over 1,000 students, campus interactions are frequent and personal. The college emphasizes a holistic educational experience, integrating academics with spiritual, social, and personal development. Students can participate in a variety of clubs and organizations, ranging from academic societies and cultural groups to outdoor adventure clubs, reflecting Montana's recreational opportunities. Athletics play a role, with the Carroll Saints competing in the NAIA. Campus ministry and service opportunities are central to the Carroll experience, aligning with its Catholic heritage, offering students avenues for spiritual growth and community involvement. Social events are often organized by student government and various campus groups, providing opportunities for connection and fun. Given the location in Helena, students also have access to the city's amenities and the surrounding natural beauty for recreation. The overall atmosphere is often described as friendly, supportive, and focused on building meaningful relationships among students, faculty, and staff.
How much financial aid does Carroll College give?
Carroll College is committed to making its education accessible through various forms of financial aid. A significant portion of students receive some form of financial assistance. Aid packages typically include a combination of merit-based scholarships (awarded for academic achievement, talent, or specific criteria) and need-based grants (determined by a student's demonstrated financial need, usually assessed via the FAFSA). The average financial aid package awarded to students can be substantial, helping to offset the sticker price of tuition. It's important for prospective students to complete the FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid) and any institutional aid applications by the specified deadlines to be considered for all available aid. Merit scholarships are often automatically considered upon admission, while need-based aid requires the FAFSA. Students are encouraged to contact the financial aid office directly to understand specific eligibility requirements, deadlines, and the types of aid available, including federal loans, work-study programs, and institutional grants. The college aims to provide aid that makes its private education attainable for a diverse student body.
What salary can I expect after graduating from Carroll College?
The median earnings for Carroll College graduates 10 years after starting their studies are reported as $61,772. This figure represents a national median and can vary significantly based on the student's chosen major, career path, geographic location of employment, and individual career progression. For instance, graduates from high-demand fields like Nursing or specialized Business areas, particularly those who secure positions in higher-paying sectors or urban centers, may expect to earn considerably more than this median. Conversely, those entering fields with lower earning potential or working in lower cost-of-living areas within Montana might earn closer to or below this figure. It's crucial to research specific salary expectations for your intended major and career field. For example, entry-level salaries in healthcare in Montana might range from $50,000-$70,000+, while roles in state government or education might start in the $40,000-$55,000 range. Advanced degrees or specialized certifications can also significantly boost earning potential. The $61,772 median suggests a moderate earning potential, with opportunities for higher earnings for those who strategically align their major with market demand and pursue career advancement.
What are the dorms like at Carroll College?
Carroll College provides on-campus housing options designed to support the student community and academic experience. The residence halls are typically traditional dormitories, offering a communal living environment conducive to building friendships and fostering a sense of belonging. Rooms are generally furnished with basic necessities like a bed, desk, and dresser for each student. Common areas within the halls often include lounges for studying and socializing, and shared bathrooms. The college usually requires first- and second-year students to live on campus, ensuring that most undergraduates experience campus living. Specific residence halls may cater to different student needs or interests, such as quiet floors for focused study or floors with specific programming. While not luxurious, the dorms are maintained to provide a safe and comfortable living space. Students have access to campus resources like dining services, Wi-Fi, and resident advisors (RAs) who provide support and guidance. For those seeking more independence, upperclassmen may have options for off-campus housing or apartment-style living, though on-campus housing is generally prioritized for its community-building benefits.
Is Carroll College a good school for research?
Carroll College, as a liberal arts institution, offers research opportunities primarily focused on undergraduate engagement rather than large-scale, graduate-level research facilities. Students have the chance to conduct research under the guidance of faculty mentors, often culminating in senior capstone projects or presentations at undergraduate research symposia. These opportunities allow students to delve deeply into subjects of interest, develop critical research skills, and gain valuable experience that can prepare them for graduate school or specialized careers. While Carroll may not have the extensive research infrastructure of a major R1 university, the personalized attention from faculty in a smaller setting can provide a more intimate and hands-on research experience. Students interested in research should actively seek out faculty whose work aligns with their interests and inquire about available research assistant positions or independent study opportunities. The emphasis is on quality undergraduate research that complements the liberal arts curriculum and fosters intellectual curiosity.
How does Carroll College compare to similar schools?
Carroll College is a private, four-year liberal arts college with a relatively small student body (around 1,092 students). It competes with other small to mid-sized private liberal arts colleges and some regional public universities in Montana and surrounding states. Realistic peers include Rocky Mountain College (Billings, MT), University of Providence (Great Falls, MT), and potentially some smaller liberal arts colleges in neighboring states like Idaho or Wyoming. Compared to larger public universities like the University of Montana or Montana State University, Carroll offers smaller class sizes, more personalized faculty interaction, and a stronger sense of community. However, these larger institutions typically offer a wider range of majors, more extensive research facilities, broader extracurricular options, and often a lower sticker price (especially for in-state students). Carroll's tuition is comparable to other private institutions but significantly higher than public options. While Carroll graduates show decent median earnings, larger universities often have stronger alumni networks and more robust career services infrastructure, potentially leading to higher average starting salaries and broader geographic placement. Carroll's advantage lies in its intimate educational environment and strong student support, while its disadvantages include fewer program options and potentially less immediate financial return compared to larger, more resource-rich institutions.
What do employers think of a degree from Carroll College?
Employers generally view degrees from reputable liberal arts colleges like Carroll College positively, particularly for the foundational skills they impart. Carroll graduates are often recognized for their strong communication abilities, critical thinking skills, and capacity for problem-solving – qualities highly valued across many industries. In Montana, where Carroll has a strong alumni presence, employers in sectors like healthcare (e.g., Providence St. Patrick Hospital, St. Peter's Health), education, and state government are familiar with the college and its graduates. The smaller class sizes and emphasis on faculty mentorship at Carroll can translate into graduates who are articulate, well-rounded, and possess a strong work ethic. While Carroll may not have the widespread name recognition of a large state university or an Ivy League institution on a national scale, its reputation within Montana and the surrounding region is solid. Employers appreciate the well-prepared graduates who are ready to contribute meaningfully. The college's focus on service and community can also indicate a graduate's potential for teamwork and civic engagement, further enhancing their appeal to employers.
Explore More
Colleges in Montana
Browse all colleges in Montana
Similar Schools
College Rankings
Research Tools
H-1B Visa Salary Data
- H-1B Salaries in Montana — Visa sponsorship salary data for Montana
- Top H-1B Sponsors — Companies sponsoring work visas
- H-1B Salary Calculator
Visit Carroll College official website
View on College Scorecard (Dept. of Education)
AI-generated analysis based on U.S. Department of Education data. Not enrollment advice. Verify information with the institution directly.